imaginary_space's Reviews (246)

medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

Much like the first book, this was still a bit "meh". I liked the plot and Kate as a character, I didn't enjoy the child (I never really do) and the mystery man constantly hitting on her in the dumbest ways possible. It got annoying pretty quickly. Towards the end, there was too much banter that wasn't funny.
challenging dark emotional sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Very poignant and disturbing social commentary on the expectations put on women, the novel becomes more and more a wild fever dream as it progresses. Several scenes were extremely heavy. 
adventurous dark emotional fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: N/A

I enjoyed a surprising number of things about this science fiction classic - unfortunately, the narration of the audiobook was not one of them.

Gully Foyle is unapologetically on a quest for revenge - good for him!
As The Stars My Destination is considered the founding novel of the cyberpunk genre, it was very interesting to see all those genre elements and compare them with modern cyberpunk works. It is also surprisingly dark for its time. Bester set out to tell a story rather than just write down his ideas and call it a novel.

But. BUT. Even though I believe Alfred Bester actually talked to at least one woman in his life who wasn't a relative (unlike Asimov), the women in this book are still ideals and objects instead of persons, and of course they flock to our hero
even though he has FUCKING RAPED them in the past
. Could have been done better. Seriously.
dark emotional sad slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Ah, Lestat, you beautiful self-centered butterfly. The love! The drama! The yearning! The EDGYNESS! 
I love to hate those characters and Anne's dark gothic atmosphere.

When I first read this decades ago, this book opening up the world of Anne Rice's vampires was what made me stick with the series, even when she stopped hiring editors.
dark mysterious reflective sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

It started strong, but ended weak. The writing is good and the reflection on life and community is interesting, but there were too many holes in the women's actions for me to believe it.
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: N/A
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

I liked:

  • The protagonist's unapologetic anger and rage and that she didn't allow herself to get sidetracked from her plan.
  • The heavy cultural and historical influence.
  • The disability representation.

I didn't like:

  • It does not really contain a love triangle, no matter how much they want to market it.
  • I've seen the video where the author talks about how the book ended up in the YA category and how the second book is much more 'them' (they didn't cut any violence to still make YA). To me, it still felt YA because of the writing, which reminds me of fanfiction, with a lot of monologuing - inner monologue and in dialogue - and everything being thoroughly explained. We get a monologue about every action, decision, interpretation, which tells us how the book got there and what to think about it. That is more YA to me than any cut or tamed violence.
challenging dark emotional tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I have to say that, so far, every book by Victor LaValle started off as either "meh" or "eh" for me, but he always turns them around until I love them. This time, though, he's writing about Weird West, with women, and he centres the story around an interesting but unknown fact from real history, real HERstory.
So that is all the things combined that I love.
I loved it from the start. This is the highlight of my reading year.

LaValle shrugs off the usual cowboy heroes and instead focuses on the outcast, the lost and the desperate. He puts them in a harsh and unforgiving world that feels very alive, and he gives them hope. In his story, they find community, receive some much-needed attention and get the respect they deserve.

The characters were super interesting. I found them fascinating: their stubbornness, their pragmatism, their mutual support. The mystery surrounding the trunk was skilfully crafted, building tension until its revelation. The ending, once again, is kind of hilarious, yet oddly fitting (a sentiment I experienced in The Changeling, too).
adventurous dark funny fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

I read these books as a teen, and wanted to see what I would think about them now. Compared to many other genre works, I was actually pleasantly surprised! 

It has all the genre classics: a heroine who's special, a hero whose "cheekbones could have been chiseled from marble", tons of tragic backstory, rather one-dimensional villains, lots of plot convenience etc. etc.

So, what did I like?


  • It's full of action – things are happening and progressing, no endless lingering, inner monologuing or stupid banter. Take this, Karen Moning's sex fae that robbed me of valuable hours of my life!
  • The action scenes are well written and entertaining to read.
  • It doesn't take itself too seriously, and it actually had me laughing a few times. Frost knows what genre she's writing in when Cat wonders about how to subtly pull out her weapon and thinks, "There was no way I could go for the surprise in my pants yet". Or when Bones manages to knock her out because she's too prude to look at him naked. Or when he makes her look him in the eye while he throws very explicit profanities at her to train her for the "flirting" of her future victims.
  • Vampire lore that follows an in-world logic.
  • Bones mostly treats Cat like an equal. He tells her what his plans are, what he wants her role to be, he gives her info beforehand and doesn't just send her into an unknown situation without context. He listens to her and doesn't expect her to just follow whatever he says. When there's conflict because he didn't tell her something, there's usually a reason other than "me genius, girl dumb".
  • I don't know, I actually found it funny that Ohio is the central hub of the supernatural world.
  • I did find myself wanting to tell Cat to get her act together with her identity crises, but she's still smarter and more capable than any other genre protagonist I've met before, and I really appreciate that.
  • For 2007, this book is very social justice aware. It's heavy-handed, but it's there and that's a good thing. The author wants to say something with her story.
  • Cat is prejudiced and she's challenged, and she learns.
  • Contrary to other authors in this genre, I think Jeaniene Frost had sex with a man at least once in her life that she actually enjoyed.

What did I not like?


  • The audiobook narrator could NOT imitate a British accent (or any accent) if her life depended on it. Which unfortunately doesn't prevent her from trying. A lot. 
  • Of course Cat is not like the other girls. Can we put this trope to rest now, please?
  • When it comes to other women,
    they either die quickly or get raped (or both), or they're Cat's competition for Bones and then they die. There isn't a single positive female relationship for Cat.
  • So much rape. Be warned.
  • Cat does turn into an irrational protagonist when the romantic subplot needs some misunderstanding.
  • The author is a US American urban fantasy author, so there's of course tons of sexual repression in the protagonist, because she has to be innocent and sexy at the same time. I'm not sure what's going on with all these authors' repressed sexuality - Mormonism? USA-ism? Bible Belt-ism? Sure, patriarchy, but it's just weird and problematic. Just let a 21-year-old woman enjoy herself, dammit! Especially when you already include a very obvious critique of black-and-white religious beliefs about good and evil.
  • Every evil guy has to be extremely obvious in his evilness. They cannot only do one evil thing. They have to do ALL THE EVIL THINGS.
  • Rape Count for this book: 6 (+ 1 that's at least coercion)
  • Times bad guys attempted to rape Cat: 6
  • One rape victim they rescue gets a very cheap out of that possible character arc because to deal with it would be inconvenient for the protagonists' plot, I guess.
  • To make Bones stand out as the good guy, he's got it all: he's a feminist, a saviour of and friend to natives, a friend with sex workers, saviour of abused women, and he even threatens to kill the guy who coerced Cat into sex before running away. Apparently, Frost finds this tricky when she wants him to come across as this anti-hero badass. So, what makes Bones stand out from all the other truly evil men is that he doesn't rape women. This means that every man who's supposed to be evil has to be a rapist as well, because how could we tell him apart from Bones otherwise?
  • I never thought I'd see the line
    "I pushed the image of my grandparents' crumpled forms out of my mind"
    right before a sex scene.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
challenging dark slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I nearly dnf'd it, because it seemed like SUCH a generic, boring YA magical girl school story. People told me it would get better later on, so I kept on reading, and it did. It got really good at times. But I think by that time, the book had already lost me and I couldn't really get into it again. I liked the characters, the mythology, the whole world building and that it's steeped in real-world history, it just seemed ... long. But then again, some plot points that seemed important were handled so quickly. I guess I'm trying to say ... the pacing and built of the story arc felt off for me.
challenging dark funny slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I can see it's clever and witty, and definitely quotable. There's a lot to discuss, and I can appreciate all of that. But still, there is such a thing as "too wordy". There's also such a thing as pretentious. Several times, I wanted to scream, "I get it, you detest society, now move the fuck on!"
Loved the ending, though.