Take a photo of a barcode or cover
challenging
emotional
reflective
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
sad
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
4.75/5
This is great!! Kyr was awful at the beginning but had a hard earned and impactful redemption arc that was very believable. She was someone I rooted for and wanted to get better knowing that she also wanted to get better. It’s nuanced but in the way that someone learning about all these issues is aware of them and starting to make connections but hasn’t quite put them all together again which fits the protagonist and her age very well. The book ABSOLUTELY DID NOT go the way I thought it would and at first I was like uhhhh this is ambitious idk how it’s going to work out… but Tesh pulled it off hot damn!!
Yeah the hair scene is weird though. I spent the whole book waiting for it and was like oh maybe they removed it and then right at the end?? It felt so weird and I trust from the evidence in the book (especially the little quotations about humanity from in universe books) that Tesh knows about these issues it just feels so out of place. It definitely made the ending a bit weaker.
All in all a very good book and tackles a lot of subjects that don’t get tackled that often in science fiction of this scale and impact!
This is great!! Kyr was awful at the beginning but had a hard earned and impactful redemption arc that was very believable. She was someone I rooted for and wanted to get better knowing that she also wanted to get better. It’s nuanced but in the way that someone learning about all these issues is aware of them and starting to make connections but hasn’t quite put them all together again which fits the protagonist and her age very well. The book ABSOLUTELY DID NOT go the way I thought it would and at first I was like uhhhh this is ambitious idk how it’s going to work out… but Tesh pulled it off hot damn!!
Yeah the hair scene is weird though. I spent the whole book waiting for it and was like oh maybe they removed it and then right at the end?? It felt so weird and I trust from the evidence in the book (especially the little quotations about humanity from in universe books) that Tesh knows about these issues it just feels so out of place. It definitely made the ending a bit weaker.
All in all a very good book and tackles a lot of subjects that don’t get tackled that often in science fiction of this scale and impact!
adventurous
hopeful
informative
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
Came for the sharks, staid for the critique of academia. In all seriousness this is a great book. It introduced me to species of sharks I wasn’t familiar with but was also a deeply personal memoir about academia and inaccessibility of it for women of colour. Jasmin Graham is an incredible advocate and mentor. I appreciated how she mentioned the many ways of knowing and learning, it’s definitely a good read if you’re wanting to get into shark science or any science really.
In terms of writing, it was very conversational and accessible. It was definitely more memoir than pop science so don’t expect too much on shark science although there’s definitely some of that. My main critique is that a lot of the information was repeated a few times which just seemed unnecessary in such a short book. It almost felt like she didn’t trust us to remember things she talked about earlier. Overall a very good book and one I might recommend for people trying to get into pop science from a social justice focus or vice versa. Also good for reluctant readers!
In terms of writing, it was very conversational and accessible. It was definitely more memoir than pop science so don’t expect too much on shark science although there’s definitely some of that. My main critique is that a lot of the information was repeated a few times which just seemed unnecessary in such a short book. It almost felt like she didn’t trust us to remember things she talked about earlier. Overall a very good book and one I might recommend for people trying to get into pop science from a social justice focus or vice versa. Also good for reluctant readers!
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
sad
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
challenging
dark
emotional
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
emotional
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
adventurous
funny
hopeful
inspiring
lighthearted
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
dark
emotional
mysterious
reflective
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
This is a strange little fucked up book but I think I liked it?
DNF at 84%. misery is so insufferable. The book started out with a lot of promise but it just got worse the longer it got. It does weird things with POV, like it’s sometimes third person limited, sometimes it’s third person omniscient? And it seems like it’s for effect but it is actually just super inconsistent and you can’t always tell what Misery thinks versus what the ?angel? telling the story is thinking? (Second issue, the bit of whatever it is telling the story seems to exist just to justify the horrible things Misery is doing)
Anyways Misery started out sometimes hating religion sometimes commenting on how badly other people are following it?And then all of a sudden they’re the Messiah and they definitely had all of these thoughts all along? And they go extremist REAL QUICK like jumping to kill all heretics, torture heretics and these are presented with no kind of hey this is actually bad and I feel like by 84% into this book there should maybe be some challenging of the genocidal tendencies of Misery and everyone else.
The voice is super weird cause it changes from a really sophisticated and high fantasy sounding voice to the completely normal way the characters speak but also because of the POV swings sometimes the narration is very proper and sometimes when it’s showing Misery’s thoughts is very plain. Think Gideon in Gideon the Ninth but done with none of the skill.
This does not feel like an adult book besides the fact that there so much sex (sometimes fade to black sometimes not? Also why did we have a heart to heart about bonds made through orgies that turn into grief when said orgy members are killed WHILE the characters were having a threesome??? Very strange) anyways, it has the tone and plot of a YA book in a bad way.
God this is so long. Final issue, it seems like the narrator is trying to set up Misery for a redemption arc but I’m sorry their actions are not redeemable they sick so much.
One final thing, the pronouns were not hard to follow but they were interested in the MOST jarring, story breaking way.
Anyways Misery started out sometimes hating religion sometimes commenting on how badly other people are following it?
The voice is super weird cause it changes from a really sophisticated and high fantasy sounding voice to the completely normal way the characters speak but also because of the POV swings sometimes the narration is very proper and sometimes when it’s showing Misery’s thoughts is very plain. Think Gideon in Gideon the Ninth but done with none of the skill.
This does not feel like an adult book besides the fact that there so much sex (sometimes fade to black sometimes not? Also why did we have a heart to heart about bonds made through orgies that turn into grief when said orgy members are killed WHILE the characters were having a threesome??? Very strange) anyways, it has the tone and plot of a YA book in a bad way.
God this is so long. Final issue, it seems like the narrator is trying to set up Misery for a redemption arc but I’m sorry their actions are not redeemable they sick so much.
One final thing, the pronouns were not hard to follow but they were interested in the MOST jarring, story breaking way.
challenging
emotional
funny
reflective
sad
fast-paced
I don’t know what to think of this book. I get what other people have said about it being a very privileged and one experience focused book but also… it’s a personal memoir so that’s kinda to be expected? People seem to want more of a universal look at BPD but I think it’s not right to speak for other people’s experiences also maybe people are just desperate for narratives about BPD from people with BPD and so they hope that they’ll find something that is their experience. Like many people say her experience is not their experience and so of course it will be different. I am a little bit tired of everyone expecting one person with a mental illness, especially someone with BPD to show the entire world of that illness especially in a short graphic memoir from a 24 year old like are we just ignoring that part?
Her experiences are very different than mine and that’s okay! I did feel seen in the thought processes more than the specific experiences and I think that’s fine. Maybe the issue is with publishing who prefer the “educated” white woman’s experience and also with psychiatry which has so many biases about who gets diagnosed with which (stigmatized) label. Yeah she’s privileged, and she should have acknowledged that a bit more but let’s direct the anger and disappointment at systems that uphold a certain narrative rather than an individual person just telling their story (who doesn’t ever say she’s going to tell anything other than her story). And again this may be my personal biases because I am angry at the system but yes! We all have biases and often look for stories that seem the same as ours in the hopes that it will that make us feel less alone (or at least that’s what I do).
I’m probably going to come back later with more proper thoughts, rn I just wish to ramble
Her experiences are very different than mine and that’s okay! I did feel seen in the thought processes more than the specific experiences and I think that’s fine. Maybe the issue is with publishing who prefer the “educated” white woman’s experience and also with psychiatry which has so many biases about who gets diagnosed with which (stigmatized) label. Yeah she’s privileged, and she should have acknowledged that a bit more but let’s direct the anger and disappointment at systems that uphold a certain narrative rather than an individual person just telling their story (who doesn’t ever say she’s going to tell anything other than her story). And again this may be my personal biases because I am angry at the system but yes! We all have biases and often look for stories that seem the same as ours in the hopes that it will that make us feel less alone (or at least that’s what I do).
I’m probably going to come back later with more proper thoughts, rn I just wish to ramble