I give it a three stars, even if a thought about giving it only two. The reason why is because i am aware that i am propably not in the target reader of this series, and even if i'm not, the serie give me some fun from time to time, even if it was a big disapointement in general. Too much love, not enough action, i always hope it will finaly explode, but never did.
I think this serie could be good for teenages girls who care more about romance, with a bit of fantasy than real hardcore crazy witch fan.

A well written thriller that work great and that is perfect for vacation, even more perfect if you go near a beach! The author kept us on the edge from the beginning till the end and the character are avoiding the stereotypes which is a good thing. Not five stars... why? The ending is a little too easy and too comforting for me. But still a good book that will make you pass a good time!

Très loin d'être aussi bien que La fille du train. Tout est mis en place pour en fair eun bon thriller, histoires de familles et de petites communautées, mystères et non-dit, meutres ou suicides, mais au final, rien ne semble fonctionner. La recette est là, mais les ingrédients ne prennent pas ensemble. Les personnages me semblaient vides et leur sort me préoccupait peu. L'intrigue ne m'a pas accrocher non plus. On se retrouve donc à survoler ce livre, sans être désagréable, mais qui nous laisse plutôt indifférent et qu'on referme dans un grand Boff. Pas une lecture à éviter, mais certainement pas un incontournable. Les attentes étaients-elles trop fortes? Peut-être, mais il n'en demeure pas moins que ce livre a un je-ne-sais-quoi qui ne fonctionne pas du tout!

Great and really dark!

A very political issues, but looking forward the next one with the return of Omega Red!! Big expectations about that one!

Interesting and entertaining new X-Men series. Looking forward to see how it will evolve and go on but it's a good start!

A very funny books that perfectly represent the reality of teaching with of course a touch of humor! All is well done and very funny, maybe even more funny if you work in education so you can relate more to it. All love it and recommend it strongly!

That is the perfect representation of what little editor, or self editing, can do at their best!

Awesome start for what look like a very promising series with Batman, The Joker and The Riddler. One hero, two great villains. Can't what to read the next one!

Close to perfection!

Still good, but definitely not as good as the first two parts of the series.