You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
542 reviews by:
ellornaslibrary
I always find myself enjoying a read by Lisa Kleypas, and this time isn't any different. At first I had a little trouble getting into the book, but quickly overcame that as I became attached to these characters. Though for this being Daisy's book, I felt like there was a lot of her sister, Lillian, in it. Eventually I began to understand why though and the importance of her, and her husband, to the story of Daisy and Matthew. I look forward to reading the other Wallflower books as well.
A sweet, humorous, and fun read for relaxing. There were moments where I was a little iffy, some issues I had in regards to editing, but outside of that I enjoyed the book. The two main characters were adorable, and I loved the surrounding characters even the perfect villian for this type of romance. I do wish there'd been a little more discussion in regards to certain discoveries(ie the curse) in more of an effort to help with the acceptance, forgiveness, and growth, but also respect that Lileas was a character who often worked through issues of that nature on her own to come to terms with them. I can respect a character of this nature as I've done this myself with certain issues.
The only other parts I was iffy about were concerning certain things like the Picts, textiles, uisge, etc. but then I read the Afterword in which the author admits to all the liberties she took along with her reasons. At that point I realized that this book is heavily more alternative/AU historical romance and not just run of the mill historical fiction. So the issues I had in that regard were easily cleared up. I can't wait to read some of the other books I have of hers as well as the other books in the Guardians of the Stone series.
The only other parts I was iffy about were concerning certain things like the Picts, textiles, uisge, etc. but then I read the Afterword in which the author admits to all the liberties she took along with her reasons. At that point I realized that this book is heavily more alternative/AU historical romance and not just run of the mill historical fiction. So the issues I had in that regard were easily cleared up. I can't wait to read some of the other books I have of hers as well as the other books in the Guardians of the Stone series.
Recommended for anyone that enjoys reading Sherlock Holmes! This is a book that has a similar feel, but makes the character its own entity instead of a clone. Also if you love the paranormal/supernatural then this book is for you as well. Beautifully done. The characters of Jackaby and Abigail are also well-developed, and I absolutely looove Abigail. Watching her grow, and experiencing that with her, is a blast. This is a great, fun read. Sadly it took me awhile due to my health, but not cause of any issues with the book! I can't wait to read the next one.
--- In-depth Review: Note that I attempted to avoid spoilers as much as possible; there may be some though no major ones. Also can be found on the To Tilt With Windmills Blog with images. ---
My Rating: 5/5 Windmills
Between the cover and that blurb, how could I not be immediately grabbed by this book, right? I had it on my Want to Read list on Goodreads for a long time, and then on the first visit to my new city’s library I saw it — and grabbed it as quickly as possible. A supernatural/paranormal Sherlock Holmes type character? That appealed to me immediately, and the mention of Doctor Who didn’t hurt either. It took me awhile to read due to my health, but each time I picked this book up I was immediately caught up in it. And it made me laugh and smile a great deal! I love a book that’ll cheer you up when you’re not feeling well.
[Favorite quote, said by Jackaby: “Hatun sees a different world than you or I, a far more frightening one, full of far more terrible dangers, and still she chooses to be the hero whom that world needs. She has saved this town and its people from countless monsters countless times. That the battles are usually in her head does not lessen the bravery of it. The hardest battles always are.”]
The descriptions in this book were beautiful whether it was Jackaby’s hat or the streets of New Fiddleham(and oh my, how I LOVE the place names in this book). My favorite though were those of Jackaby’s house; each floor giving you a clearer picture of our Detective with each word. The pond was especially breathtaking, and vivid, that it left me feeling a sense of child-like wonder and sticks in my mind. The city of New Fiddleham and the home of Jackaby at 926 Augur Lane are as much characters as Jackaby and Abigail themselves.
Some will say that Jackaby is based off the BBC Sherlock, and perhaps he was, but I have to say that I heartily feel he’s more like the Sherlock Holmes of the stories by Arthur Conan Doyle. Jackaby might at times be unaware or oblivious, but he can also be quite sociable and friendly, and even comforting, just as Sherlock of the stories. However, the most important thing here is that even with those comparisons, Jackaby can stand on his own two feet as a character; influenced in some degree though not a carbon copy. You could even say that there’s some of The Doctor in him. Which one? Well, you’ll have to read the book.
While checking out the book on some sites, I had seen some reviews where the rating was marked down for the mystery plot not being more complicated or the story not being mind-blowing enough. People are allowed to have their own thoughts though so I’m not knocking them. I just mention it cause it left me a little confused. To me this book was not mainly about the mystery. Early on it was clear to me the story is about more than the mystery, which if anything is a subplot after a fashion, even though it’s involved in a lot of the book scenes. As far as a crime mystery goes I thought it hit all the points — the Sherlock Holmes story felt here most — and added more with the paranormal/supernatural aspects. Adventure, intrigue, drama, tension, grief, excitement, urgency, and more can be felt in this entire book from the moment Abigail Rook finds herself thrust into this unusual, new life. Why? Cause you’re right there with her from the first moment, and as she grows you are witnessing the transformation from a lost girl into a self-assured woman who has finally found her place.
Now that I’ve brought up Abigail Rook, let me gush a little about her brilliance. She is everything I could’ve imagined wanting in a female lead. Here’s a young woman that wants more from life than to find a good husband and have a dozen children after finishing school; refusing to hide her intellect and dreams to fit society’s mold at a time when it is frowned upon. Instead of conforming she rebels and takes her life into her own hands. Perhaps her plan, that is really no plan at all, is foolhardy, and her first experience does not go as well as hoped, but Abigail Rook doesn’t give up and she finds herself in New Fiddleham.
This book is called Jackaby, and we definitely come to learn about, and understand, him, but to me this book is about Abigail herself. It’s about how she isn’t afraid to present a theory or give an answer even if it may be wrong, how she doesn’t buckle under the pressure or fear though it’d be understandable, how she sees things otherwise missed cause she pays attention where others do not, how she doesn’t quite believe in this new world yet opens herself up to it, and how she’s willing to protect others even at her own expense. With each page we watch her transform. Jackaby is a great character, and I really like the side characters in this book as well, but my favorite is clearly Abigail Rook.
In my opinion this book is perfect and I’m eager to read the next one, Beastly Bones, and have even picked up the #1.5 called The Map: A Jackaby Story to put on my TBR pile. This is a book that’s earned it’s 5/5 rating and I recommend reading.
--- In-depth Review: Note that I attempted to avoid spoilers as much as possible; there may be some though no major ones. Also can be found on the To Tilt With Windmills Blog with images. ---
My Rating: 5/5 Windmills
Between the cover and that blurb, how could I not be immediately grabbed by this book, right? I had it on my Want to Read list on Goodreads for a long time, and then on the first visit to my new city’s library I saw it — and grabbed it as quickly as possible. A supernatural/paranormal Sherlock Holmes type character? That appealed to me immediately, and the mention of Doctor Who didn’t hurt either. It took me awhile to read due to my health, but each time I picked this book up I was immediately caught up in it. And it made me laugh and smile a great deal! I love a book that’ll cheer you up when you’re not feeling well.
[Favorite quote, said by Jackaby: “Hatun sees a different world than you or I, a far more frightening one, full of far more terrible dangers, and still she chooses to be the hero whom that world needs. She has saved this town and its people from countless monsters countless times. That the battles are usually in her head does not lessen the bravery of it. The hardest battles always are.”]
The descriptions in this book were beautiful whether it was Jackaby’s hat or the streets of New Fiddleham(and oh my, how I LOVE the place names in this book). My favorite though were those of Jackaby’s house; each floor giving you a clearer picture of our Detective with each word. The pond was especially breathtaking, and vivid, that it left me feeling a sense of child-like wonder and sticks in my mind. The city of New Fiddleham and the home of Jackaby at 926 Augur Lane are as much characters as Jackaby and Abigail themselves.
Some will say that Jackaby is based off the BBC Sherlock, and perhaps he was, but I have to say that I heartily feel he’s more like the Sherlock Holmes of the stories by Arthur Conan Doyle. Jackaby might at times be unaware or oblivious, but he can also be quite sociable and friendly, and even comforting, just as Sherlock of the stories. However, the most important thing here is that even with those comparisons, Jackaby can stand on his own two feet as a character; influenced in some degree though not a carbon copy. You could even say that there’s some of The Doctor in him. Which one? Well, you’ll have to read the book.
While checking out the book on some sites, I had seen some reviews where the rating was marked down for the mystery plot not being more complicated or the story not being mind-blowing enough. People are allowed to have their own thoughts though so I’m not knocking them. I just mention it cause it left me a little confused. To me this book was not mainly about the mystery. Early on it was clear to me the story is about more than the mystery, which if anything is a subplot after a fashion, even though it’s involved in a lot of the book scenes. As far as a crime mystery goes I thought it hit all the points — the Sherlock Holmes story felt here most — and added more with the paranormal/supernatural aspects. Adventure, intrigue, drama, tension, grief, excitement, urgency, and more can be felt in this entire book from the moment Abigail Rook finds herself thrust into this unusual, new life. Why? Cause you’re right there with her from the first moment, and as she grows you are witnessing the transformation from a lost girl into a self-assured woman who has finally found her place.
Now that I’ve brought up Abigail Rook, let me gush a little about her brilliance. She is everything I could’ve imagined wanting in a female lead. Here’s a young woman that wants more from life than to find a good husband and have a dozen children after finishing school; refusing to hide her intellect and dreams to fit society’s mold at a time when it is frowned upon. Instead of conforming she rebels and takes her life into her own hands. Perhaps her plan, that is really no plan at all, is foolhardy, and her first experience does not go as well as hoped, but Abigail Rook doesn’t give up and she finds herself in New Fiddleham.
This book is called Jackaby, and we definitely come to learn about, and understand, him, but to me this book is about Abigail herself. It’s about how she isn’t afraid to present a theory or give an answer even if it may be wrong, how she doesn’t buckle under the pressure or fear though it’d be understandable, how she sees things otherwise missed cause she pays attention where others do not, how she doesn’t quite believe in this new world yet opens herself up to it, and how she’s willing to protect others even at her own expense. With each page we watch her transform. Jackaby is a great character, and I really like the side characters in this book as well, but my favorite is clearly Abigail Rook.
In my opinion this book is perfect and I’m eager to read the next one, Beastly Bones, and have even picked up the #1.5 called The Map: A Jackaby Story to put on my TBR pile. This is a book that’s earned it’s 5/5 rating and I recommend reading.
Aside from the fact that the end felt a little anticlimactic to me I really enjoyed this book. There were places where the writing was a little odd and confusing, like the phrasing was off or something, but otherwise I found it a pleasant read that I couldn't put down. At one point I actually made myself put it down so I wouldn't finish it too fast. This was a book that I laughed a good deal at too. The humor in it was nice, and the witty stuff was done really well -- even giving me a vibe of Stephen King at times. Also the characters were all interesting, and well-written, whether they were there awhile or only for a short time and I loved how they all linked together; even the ones you'd never would've thought linked to something did end up doing so in a manner which was really a fun little thing to come to the realization of during certain parts. This is definitely a book I'd recommend to others or pick it up again for a casual read. I'll have to add more of his work to my "To-Read" list.
