You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
Showing DNF reviews ·
Clear filter
7 reviews
Maybe will pick this up another time (as it was recommended to me and I like the prose), but I’m not in the mood for all the “wet hot shits” in this book right now 🤢
Thought it would be fun to finish this series but this book was so boring I couldn’t do it 🥲
DNF at ~20 pages. Just not in the mood for this right now — I'll probably revisit it later.
Decided not to finish this because it's so poorly researched. Just in the first 15% there's a lot of questionable history and weird anachronism — for example, eyeglasses weren't invented until the 1200s, but Mathias' father had one apparently? (It would have been a reading stone, not an eyeglass.) I was willing to shrug off the anachronisms since it's fantasy until this line in chapter nine: "In the myths and legends that [Leto] had grown up on, the girls did not—well, they did not do very much at all besides an awful lot of weaving." I can't take a book seriously when the author admitted to not reading the literature it's based on, but still writes lines like that. Margaret Atwood's Penelopiad would be a better use of my time.
DNF at 27%
Was trying to read this for a book club, couldn't get through it. I'll try again closer to the day of the actual book club meeting, but it's just way too boring, predictable, and cheesy for me 😮💨
Was trying to read this for a book club, couldn't get through it. I'll try again closer to the day of the actual book club meeting, but it's just way too boring, predictable, and cheesy for me 😮💨
DNF at 22%, not because I didn't like it but because my ereader freaked out and thought I didn't have it checked out from the library anymore, so I returned it early and placed another hold. I'll pick it back up when it's available again!
Did not finish at 45%
Accidentally checked this book out while figuring out how to use Overdrive and decided to read it. After seeing some misspellings of things in/near my hometown and finding myself increasingly uncomfortable with Winchester's tone when talking about indigenous people, I decided I didn't want to finish this book. It's a shame because I usually like his books!
Accidentally checked this book out while figuring out how to use Overdrive and decided to read it. After seeing some misspellings of things in/near my hometown and finding myself increasingly uncomfortable with Winchester's tone when talking about indigenous people, I decided I didn't want to finish this book. It's a shame because I usually like his books!