claudcloud's Reviews (310)

adventurous emotional funny hopeful inspiring mysterious fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

"A computer will perform a takeoff or landing with all the grace of a person. It is only for combat - only for the artistry of ruin - that these vessels have pilot seats at all anymore. There is something in humanity more suited to the mechanics of murder that any machine yet devised."

I was fully expecting to struggle with this book, because I’ve never read something written entirely in a mixed-media format before. I’d seen snippets of it in other books, but never 600 whole pages of it.

Suffice it to say that I did not struggle, and this was absolutely FANTASTIC.

I firmly believe that if this book had been written in any other method, it would not have been as impactful or successful at what it does. The way the story unfolds is masterful, and the fact that the reader is forced to puzzle the events together by parsing through what are effectively hundreds of pages of messages, e-mails, transcripts of audio files and official documents is very satisfying!

The plot is equally compelling as it is complex, but again, what gives the story its heart are all the characters you meet, and you can’t help but root for our main love(r)s Kady and Ezra throughout it all. They were just kids forced into a way they didn’t sign up for, but they both step up to the plate and are incredibly resilient. I’ll always have a soft spot for characters who not only are able to persevere in the face of horrible odds, but also challenge authority and stick it to the man when it matters the most. I will just tell you this, when Ezra was presumed dead and we realized that Aidan was the one talking to Kady and luring her to the Alexander? I may have teared up 😭

Speaking of characters - surprisingly, or rather not surprisingly at all, the most compelling of them all ended up being AIDAN. To go back to Osamu Dazai, what we do with our time here on this tiny planet is try and figure out how to be and become human. How to feel, how to think, how to have a moral compass, how to be part of a society of fellow meat suits who are trying to figure all of that out just as much as you are. And that’s exactly what AIDAN is trying to do, as well (albeit in their rather misguided, sometimes slightly homicidal ways). Thousands of human beings have been placed in their care, and their first instinct, the one they’ve learned from observing all the other people who have walked their corridors and gave them orders, is to protect. At all costs. To me, AIDAN is a wonderful display of humanity themselves because of this. Their understanding is still incomplete (at all costs, but to what lengths?), but I think that we’ll see more of them in the following books, since we have confirmation that they were able to rebuild themselves - perhaps we’ll see them grow even better, too.

Finally, it would be a complete oversight on my part not to mention that reading this during a global pandemic caused by a virus that can be very easily transmitted and has potentially deadly consequences (😄) is its completely different cup of tea. Again, I don’t think this story would have had this big of an impact of me if I did not know exactly what it’s like to live through something like this. Add our characters being - literally - not on earth, but confined to ships in outer space, and the sense of danger, of foreboding, of never knowing who is safe and who isn’t, of masks and hygiene regulations and botched quarantines (we’d know a thing or two about those), and it’s just... you feel it so much more. You know from personal experience how it feels, and the effect that it can have on people. And that’s not something I can say for a lot of other books.

I loved this way more than I expected to, and honestly, I’m very pleasantly surprised with how well my reading year has been going so far! I will be picking the next installments up as soon as they arrive - and I can’t wait to see more of the story, more of the files Kady got her hands on, and BeiTech’s downfall 👏🏻
emotional hopeful inspiring reflective sad
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

“I could recognize him by touch alone, by smell; I would know him blind, by the way his breaths came and his feet struck the earth. I would know him in death, at the end of the world.”

 Listen. Listen to me. I like Greek mythology a lot, and I’ve learned quite a bit about it over my years around the sun. Which is to say, I knew exactly what I was getting into when I decided to finally (FINALLY) read this. 
Did it make it hurt any less? Absolutely not.

This story is masterfully written, beautifully told, and heartbreakingly inevitable. There is nothing that can prepare you for the rollercoaster of emotions that it will take you on - and once you’re in it, you’re in for the whole ride, so buckle up! 

Achilles shines through Patroclus’ eyes. There is no one in history that could’ve painted a more honest, beautiful portrait of him, and it shows through Madeline’s writing. The love that these two boys have for each other is palpable with every single word. Patroclus keeps Achilles with his feet on the ground, while Achilles makes Patroclus brave. From the moment they meet, there’s this sense of destiny - they were fated companions, just like they were fated to fall in love, just like they are fated to die. You know that the wheels of the gods and the universe are turning at every point, and all you want is for them to stop, but you are just as powerless to stop it as they are. I’m honestly not sure whether that makes it better or worse (better, infinitely better). I’ll be honest and say that I braced myself for the pain, but I also did not expect this book to make me cry. There were so many little moments, so many little nods to characters and events that are so prominent in the history of the Trojan war that you can’t help but know exactly what their purpose is, so many instances of foreshadowing that subtly warn you, “Hey, remember the thing? Yeah it’s about to happen so be ready.” You can never be ready. As soon as we reached Patroclus’ death, I got teary, but that was it - which promptly lulled me into a false sense of security before the last 30 pages or so completely obliterated me. I’m talking sobbing. It’s been only a few minutes since I read the last pages, and I still can’t look at the cover without it making me cry again.


I’m so thankful and so happy that I got to read it, even if it’s been so long overdue. It’s the only thing I can be, with a book that made me feel so much. I will hold it close to my heart forever - and if you know me in real life and my eyes proceed to get misty as soon as I start talking about it, please don’t tell me HAHAH 
emotional hopeful inspiring reflective fast-paced

"Be bold and brave and queer. I know that’s easy to say and much harder to do. I know that some people will never be able to actually exhibit their queer identity in that way for reasons of safety.
But despite the obstacles, we have the opportunity to be a blueprint. We get to make the rules and set the terms for what our love will look like for generations to come.
Love who you want to love and do it unapologetically, including that face you see every day in the mirror.”


This book has been on my radar for very, very long now, and for good reasons. I loved it way more than I was anticipating to, and I am so thankful to George M. Johnson for stepping into their vulnerability like this and for writing from their soul.

Their memoir was decidedly not written for me - but I feel like everyone can benefit from reading it. And I do mean everyone. In reading about George's experiences, watching them mature and step into the person that they are today, I recognized some of those fears and growing pains in myself too, and I also learned how important and life-changing it is to have an environment of love and acceptance supporting you and helping you grow.

I thoroughly enjoyed and appreciated the writing as well, because I'm of the firm belief that if you can't say something in a way that <b>everyone</b> is able to understand, then you don't know your topic very well and you shouldn't say it at all. George's writing flows extremely well, while being very impactful at the same time - as you can tell, since I flew through this book in two days!

To quote B99, every time someone steps up and says who they are, the world becomes a better, more interesting place. It's extremely hard, and completely terrifying, but (to now quote the brilliant author), we are the blueprint for what's to come. And this book will contribute in making sure that we make a positive impact.
adventurous emotional funny hopeful inspiring mysterious medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

""Jeong. You never say the word, but you live it anyway. You just feel it. We instead of you and me. That’s jeong."
Gansey was aware on a certain level that the description was melodramatic, heightened, illogical. But on a deeper level, it felt true, and familiar, and like it explained much of Gansey’s life. It was how he felt about Ronan and Adam and Noah and Blue. With each of them, it had felt instantly right: relieving. Finally, he’d thought, he’d found them.
We instead of you and me."

How do I even begin to describe what finishing this series feels like? By taking a leaf out of its own book(s), I suppose.

No pomp. No grandeur. Just an ordinary Sunday, at ordinary 5:38 PM, me reading the last few lines and yet feeling like my life has been completely turned upside down - irrevocably so. It was me and a book, holding its final pages, wanting to get to the end to find out how it goes, and not wanting it to ever be over.

What can I even say to describe how much I liked reading this? I’ve said in in pretty much all my previous reviews, but I’ll say it again because it just needs to be said: I cannot believe how fast I got attached to this story and these characters. I could talk for hours about what all these kids mean to me and how their stories, individually and together, impacted and affected me, but I would fail to convey just how much they made me feel, and love. These four books now have my heart scattered through their pages forever. It’s hard for me to even think of what to focus on right now because the one word that pops into my head when I try is everything. Which I feel would be a little counter-productive (though I'm still not opposed to the idea HAHAH)

I'm sure you've already guessed by how much I love these kids that I was unbelievably excited about Blue and Gansey and Adam and Ronan (ADAM AND RONAN!!!!!!!!) finally getting their happy endings together - but I would say that the most important kind of love present in these books, and made even more evident by this final book in the series, is not the romantic kind. Rather, it's the bond that these characters have with each other that makes it shine, how they're always better together than they are apart, how much they all care for one another and how evident that is throughout this adventure that we go through with them. It’s the kind of love and trust that's as much inevitable as it is enormous, invincible, unshakeable, and in the end, it’s this forever bond that takes center stage and proves that friendship - real, true friendship - is the greatest magic out there.

This was truly, truly something special. And I will always remember the experience of reading it. It's so bittersweet to think that I'll never read it for the first time again (though I'm already looking forward to several, and I mean several re-reads in the future) - but I wouldn't trade it for the world. I adore it more than I can put into words.