1.02k reviews by:

cjeanne99

Filter
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No

This may be my last read of a Charlotte Holmes story - the Lord Ingram plot line is too annoying for me. Why can't they just get married and become a crime fighting duo without all the sexual innuendo? 
Beyond that - the plot line in this story was too contrived for me. Mrs. Watson old flame contacts her for help in retrieving some letters that incriminate her son. Moriarty is "imprisoned" in a French Chateau - and is going to release a stolen painting during a New Year's Eve Party - the chateau is used for sexual liaisons - Livia finishes her Sherlock Holmes book - Charlotte figures out the preposterous idea that the combination to the safe where the painting is being stored was transmitted via code that she intercepted - and then determines that the painting is a fake.  Too much coincidence and unnecessary side plot lines. 
reflective slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Lara/Laura Nelson reflects on her past and her experience at being Emily Webb in her high school in New Hampshire - which led her to a movie deal - and then back to being Emily Webb in summer stock in Michigan. We think the story is about Lara - but it's also about Duke - her summer romance at Tom Lake, who dumps her for her understudy when she tears her Achilles tendon playing tennis on an afternoon off. 
Set during the summer of 2020 - with the world shut down because of the COVID-19 pandemic - the Nelson family manages their fruit farm in northwest Michigan on their own. Their three daughters use the time to press their mother to tell them what they believe are the deliciously sordid details of their mother's affair with the movie star Peter Duke. They get most of the details - and they learn some things about themselves in the process. 
Some of the book feels like I'm reading Lara's diary - and she could have used some edits. It drags a bit in some places. But - still a good story.  
Loved Meryl Streep as the narrator. 
mysterious fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Loveable characters: Complicated

Mrs. Brandt's neighbor asks for her help in a "delicate situation". He met a young lady who needed his financial assistance after her mother died - and after what he believed was a one-night assignation - tells him now that she is pregnant. Mrs. Brandt accompanies Nelson to the boarding house where his beloved is living - thanks to his generosity in paying the rent. Sarah quickly surmises that something is amiss at the boarding house - from the couple who own the house, to the other boarders. When Nelson's young woman turns up dead in Washington Square, he quickly becomes the main suspect. 
How luck for Malloy that Sarah's next door neighbor is his latest suspect! As the investigation continues, the intrigue grows including a side plot involving a newspaper reporter hot on the story.
Turns out that the owner of the Boarding House was an actor - who hired other actors to live there and help dupe married men into giving the boarders money. The owner played the role of himself and his wife - which the girls who lived in the house knew - but did not share with Sarah or Malloy. Even when the rank smell from the basement (of a dead body) got bad - they didn't figure out that their host was killing off their friends. A weak spot there in the plot
  All in all - another fun read from Thompson.
adventurous slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes

Is it fiction or not? 
mysterious fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot

A young girl is found dead in City Hall park - Malloy recognizes the clothes the victim is wearing and thinks that Sarah Brandt is dead. Unknown to Malloy, Sarah had recently donated some of her clothing to a mission for “wayward girls”  - where the dead girl had lived. The wife of Sarah’s friend, and would be suitor, Richard Dennis, had volunteered at the mission before she died. Richard asked Sarah to help him understand why his wife would volunteer there - and in her usual fashion, Sarah takes charge. She organizes a fund raising party at her parents’ home, teaches hygiene classes at the mission and befriends one of the younger residents. 
As the investigation into the death of Italian-American Amelia furthers, Sarah runs into roadblocks from the Irish priests who won’t assist with the burial of an Italian Catholic, confusing stories from Amelia’s parents about her lineage - which really had no bearing on the plot, and obfuscation from Mrs. Wells when discussing her girls. 
Thompson starts to build a Richard, Sarah, Frank love triangle - going so far as to have Frank bemoaning to himself that he is below Sarah’s station and should resolve to never see her again.
But that triangle ends when Richard dies, killed by Mrs. Wells in the same way she killed his wife and Amelia and apparently other girls from the mission.

The mysteries in this series are not difficult to figure out - but they are a fun read. I also appreciate that Thompson knows her New York City society of the early 20th century - so we understand what an unusual lifestyle Sarah leads.
adventurous fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Loveable characters: Complicated

After a major earthquake destroys Edo, Japan, Chamberlain Sano is torn between helping rebuild the city, and determining the reason for the deaths of two half sisters and their incense teacher. What appears to be an innocent investigation soon turns into a plot of intrigue with some unexpected twists. 
reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No

“Nathan - for once can’t you just say an ordinary grace” - 
Nathan Drum, Methodist minister to three small congregations in 1961 Minnesota, is chastised by his wife Ruth for being prone to pontificate when a simple statement would do. But - that line doesn’t come until almost the end of the book.
Our narrator is 13 yr old Frank Drum, middle child of the Drum household, and full of the doubts and questions that fill the minds of teenagers - especially PKs. Frank is telling the story as a memoir some 50 years after the events of the summer of 1961 in New Bremen, Minnesota. 
There’s a lot of death for a three month span in a small town - but that’s partly why the summer sticks out for Frank’s memory. 
dark fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Loveable characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Pretty good for a thriller. Told from multiple POVs and three different timelines with a lot of red herrings. Quite a few spots that just made me shake my head.
  • Charlotte threatening Meredith because Marty is having an affair and Charlotte doesn't believe it's not Meredith.
  • Meredith afraid to tell Josh that she dated Marty in college
  • Meredith doesn't call the police - or tell Josh - immediately after the accident with Shelby
  • Meredith doesn't take Delilah to the doctor for a strep test
  • The fake gynecologist appointment
  • Police detective faking the DNA results - when another set of parents are wondering where their child is
So while I didn't really like how things came together - I still stayed up late at night to read the book - kept me engaged. 

dark slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I struggled with this book. I did not like Humbert Humbert - and since he is telling the story - it was challenging to keep going. 
Towards the end he references Frank LaSalle and Sally Horner - whose story is told in Rust and Stardust. That was another difficult read - but LaSalle was not the ”hero” - which made it less objectionable. 
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes

I can see why people loved this book when it first appeared in 1929. Wilder presents us with the back stories of five people who died when a suspension bridge gives way in Peru, sending the travelers plummeting to their deaths. Who were these people? Why were they chosen to die at that moment and in that manner? Wilder's fictional biographer, Brother Juniper, determines to learn what he can about the five, so he might better understand what led them to their deaths - which ultimately leads Brother Juniper to his own death.