Take a photo of a barcode or cover
christhereader8's Reviews (2.42k)
.jpg)
Right! So I borrowed this off my neighbour out of sheer curiosity and after hearing a number of conflicting reviews, I wanted to make my own mind up. Before I start, do I agree with JKR's views? Nope, absolutely not, she's still transphobic trash. #effterfs
The book itself? It's... long. Very long. At over 900 pages, it just... didn't need to be this long. There were too many random plot points crammed in that were either dragged out too long or which never really paid off. As a result, the main mystery just has too many moving parts to keep a track of (similar to Lethal White but even worse). The genuinely emotional beats are fine but it really could have been three-fifths the size and worked a lot tidier.
A lot of the initial reviews commented on the godawful timing of JKR's transphobic comments and the conceit of a cross-dressing serial killer. Is the book transphobic? Not as much as previous entries (hi there, The Silkworm), but there are still quite a lot of weird attitudes to body size and sexuality (there's a couple of examples of positive rep but at least one moment that feels very much written like a straight person writing an after-school special on The Gays).
In short, is the book worth a read? Only if you're really into the books and can contend with giving money to JKR (or you know, use a library, y'all). Otherwise give it a miss and grab another book by someone who isn't a burning garbage fire of TERF.
The book itself? It's... long. Very long. At over 900 pages, it just... didn't need to be this long. There were too many random plot points crammed in that were either dragged out too long or which never really paid off. As a result, the main mystery just has too many moving parts to keep a track of (similar to Lethal White but even worse). The genuinely emotional beats are fine but it really could have been three-fifths the size and worked a lot tidier.
A lot of the initial reviews commented on the godawful timing of JKR's transphobic comments and the conceit of a cross-dressing serial killer. Is the book transphobic? Not as much as previous entries (hi there, The Silkworm), but there are still quite a lot of weird attitudes to body size and sexuality (there's a couple of examples of positive rep but at least one moment that feels very much written like a straight person writing an after-school special on The Gays).
In short, is the book worth a read? Only if you're really into the books and can contend with giving money to JKR (or you know, use a library, y'all). Otherwise give it a miss and grab another book by someone who isn't a burning garbage fire of TERF.
Really really enjoyed this. A modern take on a murder mystery that has a lot of callbacks to the original game and the cult film (one of my joint favourite comedy films of all time). Silly and smart and fun and just a really fun ride.
I just... I love this so much. It is sweet and kind and elegant and witty and utterly lovely from head to toe. The next time you're a bit sad or a bit out of sorts, curl up with a blanket (ideally, as all reading should really be done, in autumn or winter) and a drink of your choice, and read this.
