Take a photo of a barcode or cover
funny
hopeful
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
lighthearted
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Yes
adventurous
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Loveable characters:
Yes
I came to this novel having been promised by fantasy enthusiasts that this here was a fantasy novel that had aspirations beyond imaginative fictional plots and kingdoms and magical artifacts and swords and armies. Fantasy readers seemed to have rallied behind this novel as a proud representation that fantasy can be equally as curious about the craft and form of writing as it is about speculations on weird alternative worlds.
Does the novel meet these expectations? Well, mostly. This novel is as ripe with creative settings, unique landscapes and mysterious powers as any fantasy novel. If I were better read in the genre, I would remark that it seemed to have very original fantasy ideas which eschew the sort of western European folklore and inspirations that seem to dominate the genre. As for its prose and writing, I think this novel does represent a concerted effort to focus on the technique of storytelling and not just the story itself. The conceit presented by the novel is fairly rare from what I've read in the genre (at least in fantasy I've only seen this done once in one of the final novels in the Witcher series).
The framing of the story is one of second-person perspective entering a dreamlike state encouraged by old tales told by its affectionate but fast-fading grandmother. In this dreamlike state, the character watches an old fable told by way of a live stage performance of seemingly no dialogue, and all interpretive dancing and stagecraft. The story of the stage performers, written in a more familiar past-tense third-person omniscient narrative, unfolds as a number of traditional fantasy stories do. But the framing device invites the reader to imagine, while reading this large chunk of the story, how our main character is viewing this story, not through words, but the silent stage performance of dancing and lighting and sets. In this sense, the means by which the fantasy story is transmitted back to the second-person perspective is more detached, more abstract and less coherent but its in these moments of bewilderment, when the reader pauses to wonder at *how* the story itself is being told, that the novel is at its most creative. Because the author allows for poignant and tragic excerpts of loss and war from the second-person perspective to weave their way into the fantasy story appropriately.
Even as the fantasy story progresses and the frames of the novel seem to blend and sublimate, the second-person narrative remains the strongest and surprisingly most emotional aspect of the novel. Unfortunately the fantasy story never quite reaches the heights of pathos of the story of the audience member watching said story. The final third of the fantasy story, while inventive and bold in its awareness and confrontation of the novel's framing device, loses a lot of its lustre and uniqueness in the actual conclusion of the fantasy narrative, collapsing into a readable but fairly well-trodden series of action set pieces and qualities well-explored in other fantasy novels. The first two third of the fantasy story, in comparison, are excellently imagined, with vivid illustrative prose.
There is an epilogue to the story, in which the second-person narrative quickly fades away and so it should be no surprise that it is probably the weakest part of the novel. Once the The novel loses coherence a bit here as the reader loses the sensation of only being recounted the fantasy story through the perspective of the performance's audience member and instead must reorient themselves to a traditional omniscient perspective, leaving the best aspect of the novel behind in favour of a somewhat unnecessary addendum.
Ultimately, this is a pretty unique approach to fantasy, well worth reading. The novel peaks a bit early, just after the conclusion of the second act of its fantasy story but overall the creative decisions behind the writing craft, a high-standard of prose and the framing well make up for its somewhat weaker final third.
Does the novel meet these expectations? Well, mostly. This novel is as ripe with creative settings, unique landscapes and mysterious powers as any fantasy novel. If I were better read in the genre, I would remark that it seemed to have very original fantasy ideas which eschew the sort of western European folklore and inspirations that seem to dominate the genre. As for its prose and writing, I think this novel does represent a concerted effort to focus on the technique of storytelling and not just the story itself. The conceit presented by the novel is fairly rare from what I've read in the genre (at least in fantasy I've only seen this done once in one of the final novels in the Witcher series).
The framing of the story is one of second-person perspective entering a dreamlike state encouraged by old tales told by its affectionate but fast-fading grandmother. In this dreamlike state, the character watches an old fable told by way of a live stage performance of seemingly no dialogue, and all interpretive dancing and stagecraft. The story of the stage performers, written in a more familiar past-tense third-person omniscient narrative, unfolds as a number of traditional fantasy stories do. But the framing device invites the reader to imagine, while reading this large chunk of the story, how our main character is viewing this story, not through words, but the silent stage performance of dancing and lighting and sets. In this sense, the means by which the fantasy story is transmitted back to the second-person perspective is more detached, more abstract and less coherent but its in these moments of bewilderment, when the reader pauses to wonder at *how* the story itself is being told, that the novel is at its most creative. Because the author allows for poignant and tragic excerpts of loss and war from the second-person perspective to weave their way into the fantasy story appropriately.
Even as the fantasy story progresses and the frames of the novel seem to blend and sublimate, the second-person narrative remains the strongest and surprisingly most emotional aspect of the novel. Unfortunately the fantasy story never quite reaches the heights of pathos of the story of the audience member watching said story. The final third of the fantasy story, while inventive and bold in its awareness and confrontation of the novel's framing device, loses a lot of its lustre and uniqueness in the actual conclusion of the fantasy narrative, collapsing into a readable but fairly well-trodden series of action set pieces and qualities well-explored in other fantasy novels. The first two third of the fantasy story, in comparison, are excellently imagined, with vivid illustrative prose.
There is an epilogue to the story, in which the second-person narrative quickly fades away and so it should be no surprise that it is probably the weakest part of the novel. Once the The novel loses coherence a bit here as the reader loses the sensation of only being recounted the fantasy story through the perspective of the performance's audience member and instead must reorient themselves to a traditional omniscient perspective, leaving the best aspect of the novel behind in favour of a somewhat unnecessary addendum.
Ultimately, this is a pretty unique approach to fantasy, well worth reading. The novel peaks a bit early, just after the conclusion of the second act of its fantasy story but overall the creative decisions behind the writing craft, a high-standard of prose and the framing well make up for its somewhat weaker final third.
informative
fast-paced