2.14k reviews by:

candelibri

Filter
dark emotional tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
adventurous medium-paced
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes

The entire time I was reading this, I kept thinking, this is the most fun I’ve had reading a book since reading “American Hippo.” 

I finished the book, came here to rate and log it….and lo and behold, it’s written by the same author. This was the best two hours of my life and now I just want to re-read American Hippo. 

Strong 4.5 (only because I prefer AH!)
medium-paced

A product of its time for sure. 

A funny note about the audiobook narrator…in the second short story, the characters chant the Tantum Ergo, a very popular Catholic chant. I guess no one bothered to tell the narrator because of the two settings of the chant they could have chose…they just made up their own? Very jarring. 

There is also an interesting story that makes frequent and prolific use of the n-slur. Now, while I understand the impact and the reason for the narrative arc….it was not comfortable. However the young boy’s character arc and self-discovery through the story is quite something. I’m still working through my emotions in regards to that particular story bc I’m not sure I know how else the grandfather’s racism would have been conveyed without the constant slurs that the boy would have internalized and vocalized for his approval, only to have that same disdain and vitriol then turned on him. Excellent for critical analysis yet deeply offensive and uncomfortable. Which may have been the aim. However, while yes, it may have been “a sign of the times” I think it’s a lazy excuse and could have been executed with more action. 
reflective fast-paced
Strong character development: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
medium-paced

Highly recommend the audiobook. Absolutely transportive 
emotional hopeful inspiring fast-paced
Loveable characters: Yes

So, I was gifted this book while I was in the hospital, during a very difficult stay. I think it came to me at the perfect time. Putting to the side for the moment that the illustrations are absolutely stunning (the hardcover has some of the most beautiful sheet music renderings I’ve had the pleasure of seeing) the conversations the boy and his animal friends were exactly what I needed. Yes, some of them are trite (referencing the swans “there’s a lot of frantic paddling underneath”) but it is essentially for children!

I do find it funny/sad though that a lot of the younger generation may not be able to read this beautiful book that I find so dear because of the script it is written in - yet I wouldn’t want to change it for the world! A part of its character would be lost. In any case, all of the stars and the most strenuous recommendation from me. This will not be straying far from my bedside table.