Take a photo of a barcode or cover
503 reviews by:
calamitymeat
fast-paced
adventurous
sad
tense
fast-paced
tense
fast-paced
Diverse cast of characters:
No
dark
tense
medium-paced
dark
funny
tense
fast-paced
dark
emotional
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
Maybe I'm just fucking stupid and don't understand nuance, but this has got to be the stupidest fucking book I've ever read. It prides itself on being some feminist hot take about the Trojan War/Achilles, but ends up glorifying and pitying him by the end of it. The book begins by saying the girls in the Greek war camp called Achilles "The Butcher" and emphasizing how horrible he was, however no one in the book ever calls him that or even gives him any sort of similar nickname. Despite being the "untold story of the women of Troy," the book only follows one woman, who is already a prominent character in The Illiad. Other than that, most of the women are almost entirely unsympathetic towards each other. One woman seems to be stockholmed into loving the man who picked her as his victory prize and the women do nothing but talk shit about her. They never really consider themselves in the same boat and just pity the younger or more vulnerable girls as opposed to the girls who "don't have it that bad."
The following are notes that I took while reading the last hundred or so pages:
The following are notes that I took while reading the last hundred or so pages:
- Literally what am I supposed to take away from this book. I'm genuinely not sure what this book is trying to say about Achilles
- Glorifying Patroclus
- "it's hard to remember he was one of the men who destroyed my city"
- “i didn't know which side to pray for"
- all the women's stories are told through their relationships to the men in their lives
- achilles is really important for someone whos meant to be a villain
- the women grieve patroclus after he dies
- “patroclus was a different man on the battlefield and with the women"
- very sympathetic to achilles after the death of patroclus
- his mourning process is so detailed it's very much like it wants you to take pity on him, rather than remember he's the fucking worst.
- like "oh he's so pathetic and sad" no he's a war criminal who took a living breathing woman as his prize and raped her every night and then threw a fit when he voluntarily let another man take her from him
- "they'd each grown to love their captors"
- "perhaps it was easy for me to understand why she'd love Patroclus because i'd grown to love him too"
- Around part two and certainly during part three, the book becomes less about Briseis and more about Achilles
- Achilles is too nice to Priam when he comes to beg for Hector's body
- Slowly, more and more men are humanized and show kindness to Briseis. I hate it here
- The moment of uncharacteristic and pointed sympathy when he returns Hector's body
- Another moment of uncharacteristic and emphasized sympathy when agreeing to a ceasefire for the burial rites
- I'm killing myself
- Briseis having Achilles' child
- “When he's with Briseis, he can feel Patroclus with him 🥺🥺😢😢" Die.
- "If I die I want you to marry Briseis"
- “Even if he did come back, I know he wouldn't hurt me" He killed your brother and made direct eye contact with you while yanking the spear out of his throat.
- I think it's funny that there's a VERY pointed line about turning the Trojan War into a love story. Wonder what that's about
- Briseis had a chance to escape and didn't, not out of fear for her life and is immediately shown sympathy by Achilles.
As much as I would rather shoot myself in the face than reread this book, I do want to reread it to properly gather my thoughts as I read and give a more well-thought-out review of it.
its fucking bad