Take a photo of a barcode or cover
2.83k reviews by:
betweentheshelves
Shizuka Satomi made a deal with the devil in order to play music again: give him seven souls of violin prodigies in exchange for her own. She's given him six. She's now looking for the seventh. That's when Katrina Nguyen enters her life. A transgender runaway, she's had no formal violin training. But she catches Shizuka's attention with her music. As Shizuka trains her, gets closer to her, she realizes this might be the hardest soul to let go.
What an unusual book. The writing style in this definitely isn't going to be for everyone, as Aoki switches quickly between points of view, sometimes without any warning. This is one of the only reasons I'm not giving this five stars, because the format didn't always work for me, especially at the beginning of the book. Once you get into the groove of it, though, you'll be swept away by these characters.
The characters! Your heart will break for all of them at some point in the book. Katrina's story in particular is hard to read at times, because she struggles with abuse and severe transphobia from her parents. The kindness Shizuka shows her makes her suspicious, and her journey to realizing that she can just be herself and there are people who will accept her is beautiful. I would recommend it for that alone.
Shizuka's story is also an interesting one. In meeting Katrina, and also Lan Tran the owner of Starrgate Donuts, she realizes how much love can alter her persepctive. Her character transforms beautifully throughout the book as well, moving from this cold "Queen of Hell" to someone who loves and has helped to create a safe space for someone who needed it.
I also enjoyed the blend of science fiction and fantasy in this. You get a little bit about space and space travel wtih Lan and her family, and a little bit of magic with Shizuka and the deal with the devil. All of these elements work seamlessly together, making the story and the writing difficult to put down.
All in all, if you're looking for something different and unique, I'd definitely recommend picking this one up!
Graphic: Child abuse, Sexual assault, Transphobia
Moderate: Deadnaming, Homophobia, Rape
Minor: Self harm
I would definitely recommend reading/listening to the author's note at the end, as it brings into the context the gender-swapped nature of history that the author is reimagining. I think it's a fun way to reimagine history, especially since women were so restricted at this partciular time. The emphasis on the fact that these women could do what they wanted was honestly a great take for this kind of book.
While some of the character swapping was difficult to follow (at least for me, listening to the book), I had fun reading this book and would defnitely recommend to those looking for a fun, light historical read.
Graphic: Antisemitism
Moderate: Religious bigotry, Classism
Minor: Racism
------
Moderate: Sexism, Kidnapping, Murder
This is a fun fantasy graphic novel adventure, even if it isn't necessarily the most original story. There's a lot of emphasis on the idea of found family in this story, which is great for kids that don't necessarily feel like they fit in. Our three main characters are fully fleshed out and I loved the dynamic between the three of them. It worked so well for this fantasy adventure story.
The world was also pretty well fleshed out, and while the art style maybe wasn't my favorite, it suited the world pretty well. If you're looking for a fun adventure read, I would definitely recommend this!
Graphic: Bullying
After her grandmother passes away, Shania and her mother move to Blue Rock for a fresh start. However, Shania's troubled by something her grandmother said before she died, apologizing for the lies. Shania doesn't understand what her grandmother meant until she learns more about her histroy in Blue Rock. A history Shania didn't know existed.
Let me start by saying I appreciated what this book was trying to do. Shania is white, and for most of her life, she never really thought about her race or the way race impacts her privilege. Before moving to Blue Rock, characterized as a big city, she didn't really believe she had to think about it. A lot of this book is Shania working through her own thoughts about the fact that her family's histroy is colored by racism, and that she's confronted with it every day at school. There are some important conversations that happen in this book because of that, and I think they are good conversations for what is probably a white target audience. There aren't necessarily a lot of YA books that deal with racism in this particular way, and I appreciate what the author tried to do.
However, I don't think the writing was particularly strong and overall, I don't think Shania changes enough throughout the book. The ending feels kind of abrupt, with not much resolution after a very, very slow moving story. There are hints throughout that her boyfriend, Prescott, is a bad (racist) dude, but his portrayal felt a bit disjointed? Or at least, we get more telling about what he's actually like rather than showing. We get most of our information about Prescott second hand from other characters, and while this gives the feeling that he's an incredibly violent white supremacist, it's still not really shown in the interactions we do see with him.
The interactions between characters also don't necessarily feel realistic. The plot, the characters, and the setting don't feel like they meld together very well, making the writing itself feel choppy and not very well put together. There are a lot of inconsistencies in the plot and small details, which I know it's partly because this is an ARC, but still. Shania's character didn't feel very consistent throughout, and I wanted the information about her family history to have more of an impact on her. Like, it has an impact on her, but it generally doesn't seem to change how she views the world.
Finally, this is one of those YA books where it feels like an adult writing teenage characters. There was just something about the way they were characterized and written that felt off to me. A lot of the time, they didn't really feel like teenagers in the way they talked, interacted, and just their general actions throughout. I just got a general weird vibe from the characters and didn't really care about any of them, to be honest.
All in all, even though this book is definitely tackling an important message, the overall writing left something to be desired for me. It felt very much like a debut YA, and a debut YA that needs a lot more editing before the final draft.
Graphic: Animal cruelty, Animal death, Death, Racism, Grief
Moderate: Hate crime, Toxic friendship
Minor: Violence
So apparently 2022 is going to the be year of great historical thrillers! I've read three already that are coming out this year, this one, I Must Betray You, and Daughers of a Dead Empire. They're all set in such different times, but they're stories that you definitely can't put down!
I'd definitely recommend listening/reading the author's note at the end of this, because I didn't realize it was based on a true story! I appreciated everything about the writing in this, from strongly developed characters to great pacing and little historical details that put you into this world. You can feel Hyeon's desperation to prove herself to her father, but also balance the feelings she develops for Eojin. The way the mystery unraveled also fit well with the historical era and is guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat.
Do yourself a favor and pick this one up, especially if you love historical thrillers!
Graphic: Death, Blood, Murder
Moderate: Violence, Police brutality, Abandonment
Minor: Mental illness, Torture, Grief
The writing wasn't necessarily bad, and the art was different and unique, especially if you've been reading these DC YA graphic novels. On its own as a standalone story, I think it's perfectly fine. There's not a whole lot that stands out about it. I think I just wanted something more to connect it to the overall DC universe, especially since it's published and marketed as that. Definitely mixed feelings about this one!
Graphic: Xenophobia
Moderate: Police brutality
The essential premise of this book is Andrew's best friend, Eddie, appeared to die by suicide, but Andrew thinks it was murder. The two of them are involved in some supernatural curse related to Eddie's family, and as Andrew investigates what happened to him, nothing is really as it seems. Especially with the friends Eddie made along the way.
Part Southern Gothic horror, part dark academia, the premise of the story is interesting and Madelo fleshes out the characters pretty well. While overall, some of the mechanics of the supernatural aspect of the story aren't super clear and the plot gets pretty messy at times, (which tracks with Andrew and his general life), there are some great lines and the description was 100% there. I should have written down some of the lines that impressed me, because there was some great descriptive imagery in this book.
All in all, even though this is definitely not what I typically read, I was invested until the end. This is a great addition to any spooky queer list, and would definitely be a perfect choice for spooky season. Or you know, read it whenever if you like spooky season year round.
Graphic: Death, Sexual content, Suicide, Blood
Moderate: Drug use, Homophobia, Racism, Alcohol
One of my first issues with this was the world building. It's like a modern world, but it didn't feel like one? Like, I would be vibing with the magical system and the class system, but then random technology would be thrown in, like phones. While yes, a good majority of the novel takes place in an area without electricity (which is a whole other thing), I just felt the world building itself was inconsistent and hard to get a handle on. Which make it difficult for me to get fully immersed in the story itself.
This also makes use of a lot of typical YA fantasy tropes, and doesn't really turn much on its head. Do I read more than the average person? Yes. So, that might partly contribute to it. But I wanted Rhodes to do something different with our expectations, and I just didn't find that she did. This is the first in a series, so there might be hope for future books. But I didn't find that I was invested enough to find out.
Finally, the characters. Josslyn was...fine. Jericho was fine. Most of the characters were just fine. Most of them fell flat to me, and I just wanted a bit more of a spark. Something that took them out of the general fantasy tropes they were fufilling. Something that made them leap off the page. Just something more overall!
Overall, if you don't mind YA fantasy where you don't really have to think a lot, you'd probably enjoy this book. But it was a bit of a miss for me.
Graphic: Death, Death of parent, Murder
Moderate: Alcoholism, Torture, Violence
Minor: Bullying, Kidnapping, Grief
-----
Graphic: Body shaming, Emotional abuse, Homophobia, Sexual content
Moderate: Cursing, Drug use, Eating disorder, Alcohol
Minor: Suicidal thoughts