"To Paradise" by Hanya Yanagihara is an ambitious exploration of alternate histories and futures, showcasing Yanagihara's undeniable prowess in crafting intricate worlds, however it often gets tangled within its own complexity. 

While Yanagihara's prose is undeniably eloquent, the novel's structure feels disjointed, making it a challenging and at times frustrating read. The themes and ideas presented are thought-provoking, yet their execution feels convoluted, leaving the reader disconnected from the characters and their arcs. 

The narrative is weighed down by a cast of unlikable characters whose actions and motivations often feel disconnected and difficult to empathise with. While the thematic depth is commendable, the relentless bleakness and lack of relatable protagonists make it challenging to engage with the story fully. Despite moments of profound insight, the overall experience is marred by the absence of compelling, sympathetic figures to anchor the reader's investment.

Despite moments of brilliance, the overall experience feels underwhelming and fails to deliver the emotional resonance found in Yanagihara's previous work.

A Haunting Tale of Identity and Oppression

Ghost Wall by Sarah Moss is a haunting and atmospheric novel that delves into themes of identity, patriarchy, and the weight of history. With its concise yet powerful prose and a chilling narrative, this book leaves a lasting impact on the reader.

Moss's writing style is evocative and immersive, painting a vivid picture of the eerie and oppressive atmosphere that surrounds the characters. The author skillfully builds tension throughout the story, keeping the reader on edge and engrossed in the unfolding events. The use of the ghost wall as a symbolic representation of the invisible barriers that confine and restrict the characters is particularly effective.

The characters in Ghost Wall are complex and well-drawn, with each one serving as a distinct voice in the narrative. The protagonist, Sylvie, is a compelling and sympathetic character who struggles with her role within her family and society. Moss explores the dynamics of power and control within the family structure, as well as the influence of societal expectations and gender roles.

The exploration of the weight of history and its impact on the present is another strength of the novel. Moss juxtaposes the ancient rituals of the Iron Age reenactment with the oppressive attitudes and beliefs that still persist in modern society. This examination of how the past continues to shape the present adds depth and layers to the narrative.

One aspect that may detract from the overall reading experience is the brevity of the novel. While the concise nature of the prose adds to the book's intensity, it also leaves certain aspects of the story feeling underdeveloped. Some readers may desire a deeper exploration of certain themes or a more extensive character development.

In conclusion, Ghost Wall by Sarah Moss is a gripping and thought-provoking novel that delves into themes of identity, patriarchy, and the weight of history. Moss's atmospheric writing and well-drawn characters create a captivating reading experience. Despite its brevity, the novel's powerful imagery and exploration of societal constraints make it a compelling read for those interested in introspective and haunting narratives.

Ambitious Yet Somewhat Uneven

Maggie Shipstead's Great Circle is an ambitious epic that spans decades and continents, exploring themes of adventure, identity, and the pursuit of freedom. While the novel showcases moments of brilliance and offers glimpses into the captivating world of aviation, it falls slightly short of its potential due to pacing issues and uneven character development.

The novel revolves around Marian Graves, a fiercely determined female pilot who embarks on a daring quest to circumnavigate the globe. Shipstead's vivid descriptions of the aviation world, from the excitement of takeoff to the thrill of soaring through the skies, are undeniably captivating. The author's meticulous research into the history of aviation shines through, lending an air of authenticity to Marian's journey.

However, the novel's pacing is a significant drawback. The narrative jumps back and forth between Marian's story in the past and Hadley Baxter's story in the present. While this structure allows for deeper exploration of the characters and their motivations, it also slows down the overall momentum of the novel. At times, it feels as though the story is meandering rather than propelling forward, making it difficult to fully invest in the characters and their journeys.

Additionally, the character development in Great Circle is somewhat uneven. Marian, as the central protagonist, is given ample attention and is a compelling figure. Shipstead portrays her as a complex and flawed individual with a fierce determination to defy societal expectations. However, the supporting characters, particularly those in Hadley's present-day storyline, lack the same depth and nuance. They often feel like mere tools to further the plot rather than fully realized individuals.

Despite these flaws, Shipstead's prose remains a strength throughout the novel. Her descriptions are lush and evocative, making it easy to visualize the landscapes and settings that Marian and Hadley encounter. The author's ability to capture the essence of different eras and locations adds a layer of richness to the story.

In conclusion, Great Circle is a commendable effort by Maggie Shipstead, showcasing her talent for crafting vivid prose and exploring larger themes of freedom and adventure. While the novel falls short in terms of pacing and character development, it still offers glimpses of brilliance and moments of captivating storytelling. Fans of historical fiction and aviation enthusiasts may find enjoyment in this ambitious tale.

A Captivating and Thought-Provoking Exploration

Octavia E Butler's Dawn is a compelling and thought-provoking science fiction novel that delves into themes of identity, humanity, and the consequences of our choices. Set in a post-apocalyptic world, the story follows Lilith Iyapo, a survivor who awakens after centuries of suspended animation to find herself in the custody of an alien species known as the Oankali.

One of the strongest aspects of Dawn is Butler's masterful world-building. The post-apocalyptic Earth is vividly depicted, with its desolate landscapes and remnants of human civilisation serving as a haunting backdrop. The introduction of the Oankali, a complex and enigmatic alien race, adds a layer of intrigue and mystery to the narrative. Butler's attention to detail and ability to create a believable and immersive world is truly commendable.

The exploration of identity and what it means to be human is at the core of Dawn. Lilith's journey as she navigates her new reality and forms connections with the Oankali is both fascinating and thought-provoking. Butler raises profound questions about the nature of humanity, the impact of our choices, and the potential for change and growth. The ethical dilemmas presented throughout the novel force readers to confront their own beliefs and challenge conventional notions of what it means to be human.

Lilith is a compelling and complex protagonist. Her struggles with trust, her conflicted feelings towards the Oankali, and her determination to preserve her own humanity make her relatable and sympathetic. The interactions between Lilith and the Oankali, particularly the enigmatic Ooloi, are filled with tension and intrigue, adding depth to the narrative.

The pacing of the novel is generally well-executed, keeping readers engaged and eager to uncover the secrets of the Oankali and the fate of humanity. However, there are moments when the narrative feels slightly slow, particularly during certain exposition-heavy sections. Despite this minor flaw, Butler's prose is captivating and evocative, drawing readers into the story and immersing them in its richly imagined world.

In conclusion, Dawn is a captivating and thought-provoking science fiction novel that showcases Octavia E Butler's skill as a storyteller. With its intricate world-building, complex characters, and exploration of profound themes, the novel offers a deeply engaging reading experience. Fans of science fiction, particularly those interested in themes of identity and humanity, will find much to appreciate in this compelling tale.

A Necessary Exploration of Sexual Assault

How We Disappeared by Jing-Jing Lee is a poignant and important novel that tackles the difficult topic of sexual assault during wartime. While the book brings attention to this often-overlooked aspect of history, it falls short in fully capturing the emotional impact and depth of the characters' experiences.

Lee's writing style is descriptive and evocative, effectively transporting readers to the harrowing world of the survivors of sexual slavery during World War II. The author's research is evident, and she skillfully weaves historical details into the narrative, shedding light on a dark chapter of human history.

The characters in How We Disappeared are complex and their struggles are portrayed with sensitivity. Lee explores the themes of shame, guilt, and the search for identity with nuance, allowing readers to empathize with the survivors and witness their resilience. The portrayal of the female characters, in particular, is handled with care and respect, highlighting their strength and determination.

However, the book suffers from pacing issues although the subject matter is undoubtedly difficult. Additionally, the book occasionally relies on shocking and graphic scenes to convey the horrors of sexual assault. While these moments are undoubtedly powerful, they can sometimes feel exploitative and sensationalised, detracting from a more nuanced exploration of the survivors' experiences.

Despite these shortcomings, How We Disappeared serves as an important reminder of the atrocities committed during wartime and the resilience of those affected. Jing-Jing Lee's willingness to tackle such a difficult topic deserves recognition. Although the book may not fully capture the emotional depth and complexity of the characters' experiences, it serves as a stepping stone for further discussions and awareness surrounding sexual assault during times of conflict. Readers interested in historical fiction and willing to confront challenging subject matter will find value in How We Disappeared.

A Heartfelt Story That Falls Short

Because of You by Dawn French is a poignant tale that explores the intricacies of motherhood and the impact of choices made in the past. While the novel touches on important themes and showcases French's skill for crafting relatable characters, it ultimately falls short in delivering a truly captivating and cohesive story.

French's writing style is warm and inviting, making it easy to connect with the characters and their emotions. The narrative alternates between different points of view, providing insight into the lives of several individuals whose paths intertwine. Through her characters, French delves into themes of love, loss, and the profound influence that one person can have on another's life.

The characters in Because of You are well-developed and diverse, each with their own unique struggles and flaws. French's ability to capture the complexity of human emotions shines through, and she does an admirable job of portraying the challenges and joys of motherhood. The relationships depicted in the novel, both familial and romantic, feel authentic and relatable.

However, where Because of You falters is in its execution of the overall story. The narrative jumps between different time periods and perspectives, which at times feels disjointed and makes it difficult to fully immerse oneself in the plot. The pacing of the novel also feels uneven, with certain sections dragging while others feel rushed. This inconsistency in pacing hampers the flow of the story, making it harder to become fully invested.

Furthermore, some plot developments and revelations feel contrived and lack the emotional impact they were intended to have. Certain twists and turns in the story seem forced and predictable, diminishing the impact of what could have been powerful moments.

Despite its flaws, Because of You still manages to tug at the heartstrings and raise thought-provoking questions about motherhood and the choices we make. French's ability to create relatable characters and explore the complexities of human relationships is evident throughout the novel. While it may not be a standout in the genre, fans of Dawn French's previous works and those interested in heartfelt stories of love and family may find something to appreciate in Because of You.

An Enjoyable Culinary Journey with Room for Improvement

Number One Chinese Restaurant by Lillian Li takes readers on a culinary journey through the lives of the staff at the Beijing Duck House. While the novel offers a unique perspective on family dynamics and the restaurant industry, there were certain aspects that left me wanting more.

Li's writing style is engaging and flows smoothly, making it easy to become invested in the lives of the characters. The descriptions of the food served at the Beijing Duck House are mouthwatering and provide a vivid backdrop for the story. The author's ability to capture the bustling atmosphere of a busy Chinese restaurant is commendable.

The characters in Number One Chinese Restaurant are diverse and well-developed, each with their own personal struggles and ambitions. Li delves into the complex dynamics of family relationships, exploring themes of loyalty, sacrifice, and the desire for independence. The interactions between the characters feel authentic and believable, adding depth to the narrative.

The novel also offers an intriguing glimpse into the inner workings of the restaurant industry. The behind-the-scenes look at the challenges faced by the staff and the intricacies of running a successful Chinese restaurant were both educational and fascinating. Li's attention to detail and research shine through in these aspects of the story.

However, there were certain elements that prevented Number One Chinese Restaurant from reaching its full potential. The pacing of the novel felt uneven at times, with some sections dragging while others felt rushed. This disrupted the flow of the narrative and made it difficult to fully immerse myself in the story.

Additionally, while the characters were well-developed, there were moments when their actions and decisions felt inconsistent or lacking in depth. Some plot developments felt contrived and forced, detracting from the overall believability of the story.

Despite these shortcomings, Number One Chinese Restaurant remains an enjoyable read. Li's ability to weave together the complexities of family, love, and ambition within the backdrop of the restaurant industry is commendable. If you're a fan of character-driven stories with a culinary twist, this book may be worth exploring. However, if you're seeking a tightly paced narrative with flawless execution, you may find yourself wanting more.