Take a photo of a barcode or cover
anastasiaf's Reviews (257)
The Strange Case
Nick Luddington, Laurie Kirwan-Ashman, Mitali Jahagirdar, Fallon O’Dowd, Derek Kolstad
Interesting, definitely unexpected, felt a little cheesy at one bit but wrapped up well enough
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Loveable characters:
No
I don’t know how to feel about this book, but that’s mainly because I’ve forgotten what happened in this book vs the one before.
It feels very slow, written as a screenplay for a TV show from the 2010s - so much happened and yet nothing really?
It has interesting characters and ideas, but something fundamental is missing. Curious to read what others think.
I will still read book 3 (if/when it comes out, but I kind of hope it’s the last one).
———
It feels very slow, written as a screenplay for a TV show from the 2010s - so much happened and yet nothing really?
It has interesting characters and ideas, but something fundamental is missing. Curious to read what others think.
I will still read book 3 (if/when it comes out, but I kind of hope it’s the last one).
———
- agreed that author’s writing has clearly improved a lot since the last book
- I didn’t like marcella, unlike others
- Didn’t love the back and forth again, SPOILER and I’m especially confused why so much time was spent on it when Marcella didn’t ultimately matter that much and she was killed anyway?
- Eli’s backstory is so tragic, and the parallels were tough to read (in a good-writing way)
- Sydney’s story didn’t go anywhere really, which was annoying
- I wish this had been shorter and/or the end of the series
- SPOILER I was worried nothing was really going to happen after the marble broke, but then so much did in quick succession? It was a little jarring
- Someone said the author doesn’t know if she’s going to write a third book? That’s so confusing as this was not a satisfying end at all.
- Did we ever get an explanation of why June cared so much about Sydney?
SPOILERS
- started boring and slow (but might have just been because I was listening in 30 min bursts)
- Got interesting as we got into the concept of Eli killing EOs
- Got boring again towards the end re the final meet up. Felt a little like a pacing problem
- It feels like it was written as of explaining a film that’s being watched - the translation causing a pacing problem
- I’ve loved (and felt okay) about other books by this author, but this is my least fav. Still interested enough / hopefully enough to try book 2
More if a story than the first book, but kind of boring.
Agreed with another reviewer - probably could have condensed to half the length of this book.
Lots of good ideas - I’m excited for how the tv show will do this story.
Agreed with another reviewer - probably could have condensed to half the length of this book.
Lots of good ideas - I’m excited for how the tv show will do this story.
3.9
Confusing and a little too long in parts. Brought in some interesting lore. Curious how the next book will be.
Confusing and a little too long in parts. Brought in some interesting lore. Curious how the next book will be.
It’s an interesting premise and written well, but it’s just too high scifi for me and I’m bored and confused. I did read a detailed summary and thought it was an incredibly interesting and creative story and listened to another hour but it’s just not for me right now. It would be perfect for people who like this type of scifi and deserves all the hype.
SPOILERS
Wow, the beginning on the ship was sooo boring. I almost gave up. Maybe it was so long because I was seeing family and having shorter listening times, but still.
Again, there were really interesting ideas but I think they went a little further this time (re cloning, nature vs nurture, etc)
I think the pacing choice didn’t work as well as hoped - it was just frustrating to hear the Mithinrood people assume that Koli was coming to do bad instead of just asking when we heard his point of view.
I was also so pissed when it felt like we just glossed over Koli dying, but I guess it made sense (though it would have been better to cut the narrative at his upload and the question of if it was done in time).
Thinking about the series as a whole, it felt like a decently unique and interesting story, that was just way too long, took some odd choices which didn’t pay off with the style (pacing, language, etc) which makes it feel like maybe it’s the author’s book (which it isn’t) or first try to make such a huge story (which it arguably is)
Overall series score 3.75*
Wow, the beginning on the ship was sooo boring. I almost gave up. Maybe it was so long because I was seeing family and having shorter listening times, but still.
Again, there were really interesting ideas but I think they went a little further this time (re cloning, nature vs nurture, etc)
I think the pacing choice didn’t work as well as hoped - it was just frustrating to hear the Mithinrood people assume that Koli was coming to do bad instead of just asking when we heard his point of view.
I was also so pissed when it felt like we just glossed over Koli dying, but I guess it made sense (though it would have been better to cut the narrative at his upload and the question of if it was done in time).
Thinking about the series as a whole, it felt like a decently unique and interesting story, that was just way too long, took some odd choices which didn’t pay off with the style (pacing, language, etc) which makes it feel like maybe it’s the author’s book (which it isn’t) or first try to make such a huge story (which it arguably is)
Overall series score 3.75*
Really interesting and well thought out ideas, but it just didn’t quite get there for me. I do wonder if some of the issues were due to the audiobook narrator as I felt like her tone made the story tension feel less serious.
I guess I didn’t care about it enough because I didn’t go look at other reviews and write detailed notes after.
SPOILERS
Characters make some strange choices.Like not running away from the railings when the first person is killed by the mermaids. Giving a whole monologue while the captive mermaid can hear. Etc.
I guess I didn’t care about it enough because I didn’t go look at other reviews and write detailed notes after.
SPOILERS
Characters make some strange choices.
“Write your own ticket” I don’t think I’ve ever heard this phrase in my life as much as I’ve heard it in this one book.
The music during the credits would have been perfect to have DURING the reading….
I like that we got Spinner’s perspective, I like that we learn more about tech. Interesting enough story that I bought the next one immediately