The first half was slow ajd I found myself getting annoyed at Shoehanna for her impulsive immature ways . But the second part was cute and moved quicker. I really loved the mall and bookstore setting and it was nice to see some diversity in holiday reads . It was a cute ok holiday read. 

read in one day .

Way way way too focused on covid and the pandemic without touching on other things. I like that it had covid in it because we need those stories but it just was only covid. The romance was odd and under developed and really it just felt like a wear your mask and social distance story 

My issue with this other than the other ones was that I felt parts dragged on and it tended to get repetitive . Still really well done but I liked the previous two more. The last 20% of this book though was my favorite and it made me super tense throughout 

This book is pure magic. I need to come back and write more of a review but I want to capture my in the moment feelings which is happiness at the wonderfulness of thos book and the characters and the sadness that it’s over. I cried multiple times while reading this as well as had a myriad of other emotions. This is the type of book you want to hug and make everyone read it