You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

835 reviews by:

abandonedquests

Filter

2 reviews

The Stardust Thief

Chelsea Abdullah

DID NOT FINISH

I was excited to read The Stardust Thief, and it's a fairly solid fantasy, but it didn't quite work for me.

The premise is fun: Loulie is a young thief with a jinn bodyguard, and they meet and save Mazen, a prince in disguise. They have to find a magic lamp and navigate a conflict between humans and jinn. There are references throughout to tales from 1,001 Nights.

I really enjoyed the world Abdullah created: it feels alive, full of colour and sound. The magic is intriguing and I was interested in the history and myth that brought us to the start of the novel. I loved the emphasis on the power of storytelling.

Unfortunately, I never became fully interested in the current-day characters and plot as I was reading. Loulie and Mazen feel a bit like generic YA fantasy characters for me, and the prose is fairly basic, with awkward dialogue. It reads quite young, though seems to be marketed as adult fantasy. (And I love YA fantasy -- but this one just didn't grab me.) I'm a reader who loves interesting characters and a strong voice. I wound up reading halfway and deciding not to finish this one.

However, I think readers who are more plot-driven will find a lot to like here. As I mentioned, the world is interesting and immersive, in a way that (for me) the characters aren't. It's a solid book, just not to my personal taste.

Thank you to Orbit Books and NetGalley for my review copy of this book.

Swift the Storm, Fierce the Flame

Meg Long

DID NOT FINISH

I adored the first book in this series, Cold the Night, Fast the Wolves. The sequel, Swift the Storm, Fierce the Flame, is well-written but didn’t appeal to me personally as much.

In Cold the Night, the novel focused mainly on the heroine Sena and her new wolf-friend Iska competing in a cross-country dogsled race on a frozen planet. I’m a huge fan of wolves, adventure stories, and frozen landscapes, so it felt like the book was written just for me.

Swift the Storm takes us to a jungle planet, and gives us a new narrator, Remy. Remy appeared in the first novel, and she takes Sena and Iska with her to this new planet Maraas to try to find a friend she lost two years ago.

I found this one harder to get into. I’m not normally a huge fan of crime syndicate stories and stories of double crossing and corporate politics, so the emphasis on alliances and betrayals was less interesting for me than the survival focus of the first book. There’s also a lot of time spent on Remy thinking back to her previous failed missing and the lost of her friend, Alora.

I wound up deciding not to finish this one at the halfway point, unfortunately. It’s not a bad book, and I think it will find an audience among people who love a good YA spy/sci-fi story. But I found after a few weeks of letting it sit, I just wasn’t looking forward to continuing.

Thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday Books for my review copy of this book.