I loved this book I loved the historical setting and the magic and the romance it was so very good. I really liked the characters especially Camille and Lazare I really liked how their relationship developed I really disliked Alain worst brother ever although Sophie could be annoying at times she was not unlikeable. I villain Seguin was interesting and well written the dark magic that the story describes has more to do with him than the protagonist of the story Camille he was just a very good villain. I really liked the plot of the story the magic mixed with pre French Revolution time period I liked that Camille would do anything for her sister and I really enjoyed the well written romance in the story. So overall I loved this book would read more by this author.