Take a photo of a barcode or cover
awesomeeallyson 's review for:
One Dark Window
by Rachel Gillig
adventurous
dark
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
N/A
I love going into a book blind, and that’s what I did with this book. I saw some hype and generally felt like I would enjoy it based on my personal taste, which I did. But I think part of the issue with why I didn’t like the book, is that I am just getting drained reading YA fantasy. I love the romance in fantasy, but I I want more of the fantasy and world building which this book just didn’t have. The tarot card style magic was intriguing and the monster in Elspeth’s head was creative. But I wanted more background. More history. A more intricate magic system.
The romance to me felt predictable and also what happened to Alyx? He just disappeared? Also I expected more from Ioth and her storyline kind of fizzled out as well. Granted, those are all side characters but they seemed important when we were introduced to them.
The plot it self was really interested and probably my favorite part of the entire book. There was some really creative elements woven into the storyline that kept my interest and some of the scenes really sucked me in, while others I found myself skimming. The pacing felt a bit rushed overall but that didn’t end up taking away from the book. It just made it feel like a faster and lighter fantasy almost? This is definitely a good book and one I’d recommend, I just think I personally need to take a break from YA Fantasy.
The romance to me felt predictable and also what happened to Alyx? He just disappeared? Also I expected more from Ioth and her storyline kind of fizzled out as well. Granted, those are all side characters but they seemed important when we were introduced to them.
The plot it self was really interested and probably my favorite part of the entire book. There was some really creative elements woven into the storyline that kept my interest and some of the scenes really sucked me in, while others I found myself skimming. The pacing felt a bit rushed overall but that didn’t end up taking away from the book. It just made it feel like a faster and lighter fantasy almost? This is definitely a good book and one I’d recommend, I just think I personally need to take a break from YA Fantasy.