Kind of between a 3 and 4. I really dug the art, but the story kind of fell apart by the end. I think the idea of seeing someone commit a terrible crime can be really well done. And the fact we can try to change that outcome, and maybe make that person not kill someone, is really interesting. But overall I feel it didn't pack the emotional punch I was hoping for when I was first reading it. Still, well worth the read for the art alone and solid characters.