Sierra Simone returns with Midnight Mass, and it packs a punch to the gut, a sizzling continuation of Tyler and Poppy’s story, taking readers on a raw, emotional, and deeply intimate journey. As a sequel to Priest, this novella delves deeper into the complexities of faith, desire, and the price of love when the soul itself is caught in the crossfire.

Simone masterfully weaves together themes of guilt, redemption, and devotion, painting Tyler as a man torn between his spiritual calling and the overwhelming love he has for Poppy. The emotional stakes are high, and Simone does not shy away from exploring the darker, more vulnerable aspects of their relationship. Tyler’s struggle to reconcile his past and present makes him an achingly flawed yet relatable character, and Poppy’s unwavering passion and strength anchor the story in a way that feels both empowering and gutwrenching.

True to Simone’s signature style, Midnight Mass is unapologetically steamy, with the eroticism serving not just as a backdrop but as an essential element of the couple’s connection. The scenes are bold, intimate, and deliciously sinful, yet they never overshadow the emotional depth of the narrative. I do wish Poppy and Tyler had done more talking and less of the... other thing, but nonetheless, it is a beautiful follow up.

This novella is not just about the physical and emotional trials of Tyler and Poppy—it’s also about growth, forgiveness, and finding light even in the darkest moments. Simone’s lyrical prose elevates every scene, from the searingly passionate to the heartachingly reflective, making this a must read for fans of the first book.

Midnight Mass is a perfect blend of temptation and redemption, passion and pain, and it serves as a deeply satisfying follow up to Priest. For mature readers who enjoyed the first book, this sequel will leave you breathless and contemplative, reminding you that even the wicked deserve love and grace.