erinreadstheworld's profile picture

erinreadstheworld 's review for:

The Spill by Imbi Neeme
3.0

The Spill starts with a car accident on a remote road in Western Australia. No one is hurt but the family feels its impact for decades.


The book has an interesting structure. The chapters set in the present are told from two perspectives, alternating between sisters Nicole and Samantha. Chapters that take us back to the past, through the 80s and 90s, are narrated from the third perspective and are titled 'Piece #...' It's unclear whether these chapters are piecing the puzzle together, or whether they're picking up the pieces of a broken family. Or if we even see all the pieces.


There's quite a few layers to the book. Imbi Neem explores the different way two people experience the same situation.  No two people have the same truth, especially when they're sisters. We see this again and again throughout the novel. Whose version of an event is the truth? It's impossible to say, especially when looking back at the past.


The book also explores addiction and alcoholism. Again, there's lots of layers to unpack. We see how alcoholism can unravel a family. How addiction can be genetic. And Imbi Neeme touches on the way the Australian drinking culture often accepts problematic drinking as something normal. Are you an alcoholic or the life of the party?


The idea that hurt people, hurt people is also explored. Is a character unlikeable or simply struggling with their own demons?


The Spill sets out to comment on a lot of issues that Australian families face. Alcoholism, divorce, splintered relationships. For a book that explores a lot of heavy topics, it never feels too traumatic.


The book was good but didn't wow me. I have seen plenty of rave reviews and it did win Imbi Neem a Penguin Literary Prize. The Spill would certainly make a good book club book. There's lots to be unpacked and discussed.


⭐⭐⭐