maxarcreads's profile picture

maxarcreads 's review for:

The Tryst List by Kaylene Winter
3.75

This was a 3.75 for me. I did enjoy a lot of parts about this book but there were some things that didn't hit for me. The start of this book was really good, and I loved how they originally connected and then separated and how they ended up back together. The tension that built up when they were trying to pretend, they didn't know one another really built up the tension making me wonder who would break first. I loved it all and the spice throughout the book was there and steamy!!!

But I will say once the two of them were together there were points in reading their relationship that I found less enjoyable. I think what it was is I really identified with Peter who has suffered trauma from his family and how he grew up while Jordan had a really happy home life and I think at times Jordan didn't understand how trauma can really affect so deeply. Like yes, I get that Peter promised to only tell the truth at certain points but had not disclosed certain things in his past until he was confronted by them. He always owned up to it and apologized and explained it but the fact that he didn't disclose it asap really upset Jordan that I think someone who doesn't understand this kind of trauma can understand. You can seriously love someone and want to tell them everything but some things you still keep to yourself out of fear and trauma. This was a new relationship and yes they loved each other but it takes time to build up that level of trust and vulnerability. 

At one point shortly after they declare their love to each other Jordan says there is a level of immaturity in their relationship, and they have to grow more in their relationship before they can say they love each other again. I think that is spot on for their relationship. While Peter was no angel he did when confronted with an issue apologize, explain and try to do better. But I would sometimes feel Jordan's responses were just a little on the immature side. 

But when things were sailing smooth in their relationship, I really enjoyed reading the two of them together and their chemistry was off the charts. It was just when their relationship hit bumps and their responses to those bumps that I didn't really enjoy. 

I think what stopped this from being a 4 is that I was a little let down by one of the "trials" that was going on in the book. That being Peter's relationship with his parents and the building up we got throughout the whole book to find out what the secret was and how he would respond to his family's constant blackmail. When it came to the wrap up of that all we got for a conclusion was him admitting to the error he made and a resolution to fix it no matter what the professional costs. But we didn't actually read the steps he took and his family's reaction to losing their leverage. It just felt a little anticlimactic to have all this buildup and just get his action plan to the problem but read the carrying out of that plan. 

In the end I did enjoy this book for the most part. I found it to be a super spicy book and while I did enjoy the highs of Peter & Jordan's relationship there were areas I didn't enjoy as much and areas I wish had been expanded more. 

This book is about a wild night in Vegas between two souls that connect by pure chance. After A magical night, Peter the next morning is acting cold towards Jordan and walks out leaving Jordan embarrassed and questioning everything. Years later after they have both become successful in their respective fields, Peter decided now was the chance to rekindle their connection and make up for the biggest regret of his life. But will old resentments keep them from reconnecting and if they do reconnect will old secrets break them before they have a real chance of something special. 

I recieved a free arc copy in exchange for an honest review.