Take a photo of a barcode or cover
creepshowcassie 's review for:
Mrs. S
by K. Patrick
reflective
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
On paper, Mrs. S was a story I thought I would love. The synopsis instantly hooked me in: a novel exploring the nature of queer love and attracting, the power of desire, set amongst the backdrop of a boarding school. It explores forbidden relationship dynamics as a butch lesbian falls in love with a married woman - the wife of the school’s headmaster. It was described as “seductive, stylish, and disarmingly wry” and that’s exactly what I was looking forward to. Unfortunately, this description totally missed the mark.
The major gripe I had with the book was the writing. It was not well-written. The sentences were choppy and disconnected. When characters spoke, there were no quotation marks, no line breaks, making it increasingly difficult to follow who was speaking and when. Each sentence was so disjointed that I could not think of anything else. There is no flow in the writing - every sentence. Reads. Like this. And it is so, so distracting! Not only that, but it was so dry it felt like I was reading an instruction manual. Nothing about the writing was seductive or stylish. It was brusque and difficult to understand.
The book was also a slog to get through. Ultimately, I should have DNF’d it (which seems to be a habit of mine lately, but I’m trying to catch up on my reading goal) but a book with less than 300 pages should not take me more than a month to get through. There really was no plot to speak of, which I do expect with literary fiction, but when that is the case, I expect the characters to be the focus. However, the characters in the novel are so flat and uninteresting, there was nothing for me to latch onto or really care about. None of the characters have names, aside from Mr. and Mrs. S, and are only referred to by their titles, which gives a great feeling of disconnect and makes them impersonal.
I found the dynamic between the narrator and Mrs. S vaguely interesting, but not interesting enough to be invested. The power of desire was minimal and what intimate scenes their were were so lacking that I found that there was no desire at all. There’s nothing more to their relationship other than sex and the forbidden aspect - the narrator is the affair partner - and it ultimately goes no where. The narrator had much more chemistry (and even then, that was minimal) with the character of the Housemistress. The forbidden romance was lackluster and aimless, which is a shame because it’s supposed to be the focus of the novel.
Ultimately, I was really disappointed in this one. I’ve come to the conclusion that stories that are just one, long chapter with small cuts or line breaks are not for me. On paper, this sounded like a story I would’ve loved, but due to the stylistic choices, pacing, and lack of character focus or development, Mrs. S. lowest rating this year so far.
Graphic: Sexual content, Lesbophobia
Moderate: Infidelity
Minor: Drug use, Alcohol