I'm not really sure how to rate this one. The layers of storytelling and descriptions were one of the things I loved most about this book. It was a page turner that had me delving in wanting to know more and find out what happened. So judging it based on that it is really stellar. But I didn't like the storyline when it was flushed out. And in the end, none of the characters were all that like able. I didn't figure it out ahead of time. And I was completely disgusted by the events that transpired.