ozmeister_books's profile picture

ozmeister_books 's review for:

Free from Falling by E.L. Massey
1.75
hopeful lighthearted slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I wanted to like this. Desperately. It seemed like the perfect premise and a fun way to get me back in this universe for the second half of Eli and Alex's story that I was only halfway invested in. (That's a separate review, that I have already written) But between the hockey, the rockstar-dom, the whole thing with the cattle ranches, and
the random cancer diagnosis subplot
there were too many things going on in the plot for me to feel attached to any of it.
The playoff push alluded to in the synopsis is mentioned maybe once, and the aforementioned cancer diagnosis is just...not resolved. There's no conversation about it between Matts and his father, and almost no consideration of how his father's cancer would affect Matts going into a new relationship.


Besides that, the romance is...fine. Aggressively fine. It comes off like the pair have too much in common to make logical sense, and it's not doing anything memorable on an emotional level. It hits a few clichès and it makes no sense to the reader why they wait so long to get together because we can tell they are obsessed with each other so soon.

The writing can only make up for that so much. In other books I've found mediocre (or bad, this is bordering on bad) I've found something to praise about the wit or general execution. 
But you can only pull off so many Shakespeare references before it becomes utterly ridiculous, and the amount of times that something along the lines of "this is fine!" followed by a time skip and "this is not fine." was written was enough to make me feel a little insane.


I like to find some basis on which to recommend a book even if it's not my thing. But with this one...? It was absolutely something I would expect to enjoy and...while it wasn't bad, it did nothing for me after the first half. Just find another hockey romance; there's enough out there.