I think this might be a case of "It's not the book, it's me".

This book is Groundhog's Day meets Hallmark Christmas movie and since I am one of the 4 people on the planet that doesn't like either of those things this just didn't do it for me. (Yes, I know. I am an AVID romance reader who doesn't like Hallmark movies. I don't understand it either.)

Also, I spent 3/4 of the book terrified that she was going

Spoiler

to have sex with both brothers. I'm very grateful that she didn't, but I thought the book was going to be about her and Theo and when we took a right turn to Andrew I was confused. I just kept expecting her to end up with Theo. It is mentioned several times throughout the book that family members think Theo is in love with her...and then all of a sudden no one mentions it again? That just never resolved.

So, that just really put a wrench in my enjoyment of the book.