This was just as good as McManus's first book, One of Us is Lying! Once again she told the story (through the perspectives of two characters this time) in a suspenseful way that kept me guessing right until the end! Only this time, I didn't figure out who the killer was as early on.

I loved the mystery of trying to connect the missing homecoming queens with Ellery and Ezra's aunt who went missing years ago. Just as well, I loved the setting (I absolutely LOVE Vermont!) and I really think that Ezra and Mia need their own book now. They were just two amazing, outspoken characters that didn't get enough page-time.

Another great YA Mystery/Thriller for anyone who loves the genre!