Take a photo of a barcode or cover
nikosreadsbooks 's review for:
Return To The Black Farm
by Elias Witherow
dark
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
It’s giving unnecessary sequel vibes. But if Elias Witherow absolutely had to write a sequel, let’s be real Nick and Jess should’ve sat this one out. Danny deserved the spotlight here.
What drew me to this sequel was the promise of diving deeper into the Black Farm itself. The world building in the first book was top tier and that remains the same here: creepy wendigo horses? Faceless creatures stalking Nick? And while the Black Farm remains the best part of this book (it still eats, don’t get me wrong) everything else feels like an afterthought.
Those last two chapters? They’re the narrative equivalent of a jump scare you didn’t ask for. If we could just Thanos snap those out of existence, this would’ve been a solid 3 or 3.25 for me.
Overall, I respect Elias Witherow for revisiting this unsettling world, but honey, sometimes you have to leave the party while it’s still iconic.
What drew me to this sequel was the promise of diving deeper into the Black Farm itself. The world building in the first book was top tier and that remains the same here: creepy wendigo horses? Faceless creatures stalking Nick? And while the Black Farm remains the best part of this book (it still eats, don’t get me wrong) everything else feels like an afterthought.
Those last two chapters? They’re the narrative equivalent of a jump scare you didn’t ask for. If we could just Thanos snap those out of existence, this would’ve been a solid 3 or 3.25 for me.
Overall, I respect Elias Witherow for revisiting this unsettling world, but honey, sometimes you have to leave the party while it’s still iconic.