You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
orcinus_olive 's review for:
The Mermaid, the Witch, and the Sea
by Maggie Tokuda-Hall
adventurous
dark
mysterious
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Tldr:
Unfocused mess that doesn't seem to know what it wants.
The bland main characters and their strange plot progression take away pages from the much more interesting side characters and their more engaging and better executed side story.
The world seems genuinely interesting with a lot of potential but the author doesn't seem to really grasp which parts of the world are the ones that make a good narrative.
Long version:
Let's start by unveiling the plot progression for the main characters.
Flora/Florian is a pirate crew member and wants to save up some money to build up a life with her/his brother in their ancestors' homeland (that they visited once for like a day).
Flora falls in love with Evelyn and snitches her brother to run away with Evelyn.
Flora strands on an island with Evelyn, they get separated and Flora learns magic from a witch.
Flora realizes that she does care about her brother, meets up with Evelyn and they return to the pirate ship to save her brother.
Flora dies and she and Evelyn become mermaids.
The end
It reads a lot like the author has constructed an interesting world (it is quite interesting in parts) but didn't really know how to fill it with a plot. So she just wrote without a clear end goal in mind and then decides she came up with a cooler end goal several times without changing earlier chapters in accordance.
Also Florian as a main character is not really enjoyable. S/he is incredibly passive and gets pushed around by others all the time. First his central motivation is to keep his brother around and well. Then Evelyn drags him to be around her and have fun with her. During their together escape, Rake tells him to abandon his brother.
On the isles, she just abandones Evelyn because they get separated (Evelyn is being captured by soldiers) and the witch just says "Well she didn't actually want you." which Florian - a character with clearly established trust issues and natural scepticism - just believes.
Even once he made the conscious decision to abandon the witch and save Evelyn and his brother, Evelyn has already saved herself and agrees they need to return to the ship for her own reasons.
Evelyn by the way is a better character. She's a well executed "rich girl who doesn't know how the world works for poor people" that doesn't get annoying most of the time.
However I still think she's rather bland compared to Rake and Lady Ayer, two important side characters to either Flora or Evelyn, who have their own story and motivations going on with each other. Rake in fact I liked so much that my favorite DnD OC is basically him but as a woman.
They have actual defined goals and methods two achieve them. They have interesting development and foreshadowed plot twists. All things I would argue the actual main characters lack.
In fact I would say the entire story thread of the triangular relationship between the nameless pirate captain, the pirate supreme and the empire's army has all these things too while the MC's story lacks all these things.
But instead of elaborating on that, almost half of the book is spent talking about how Evelyn is imprisoned on the floating isles being bored while she waits for Flora to rescue her. Meanwhile Flora sits with the titular witch and learns the methods and lore of the magic system.
I will admit, the magic system is unique and actually interesting. There's just one problem.
It serves no purpose. It could be removed entirely and it wouldn't change a thing. Effectively all conflicts that the magic resolves are caused by the magic. In fact the story would almost benefit from removing the magic, because then the middle part would be so much less of a slog.
Also this story beat made me realize why "Oh this character seems evil, so you assume they're just weird but ultimately good. Oh surprise, they actually are just evil." is a bad and unsatisfying way to write.
Plot twist: Evil person tells the MC "You will regret this." and MC never regrets it. What was the deal with that?
Summary:
So yeah, ultimately I can see a lot of potential in this world, but it wasn't very well used. It feels like the author crammed just as many of their ideas as possible into the pages without any form of cohesion or theme.
If the focus was shifted away from Evelyn and Florian, I could see myself enjoying this. But the two and their story were just bumming me out so much and consumed so many pages that I ultimately wouldn't recommend this despite its potential.
Unfocused mess that doesn't seem to know what it wants.
The bland main characters and their strange plot progression take away pages from the much more interesting side characters and their more engaging and better executed side story.
The world seems genuinely interesting with a lot of potential but the author doesn't seem to really grasp which parts of the world are the ones that make a good narrative.
Long version:
Let's start by unveiling the plot progression for the main characters.
Flora/Florian is a pirate crew member and wants to save up some money to build up a life with her/his brother in their ancestors' homeland (that they visited once for like a day).
Flora falls in love with Evelyn and snitches her brother to run away with Evelyn.
Flora strands on an island with Evelyn, they get separated and Flora learns magic from a witch.
Flora realizes that she does care about her brother, meets up with Evelyn and they return to the pirate ship to save her brother.
Flora dies and she and Evelyn become mermaids.
The end
It reads a lot like the author has constructed an interesting world (it is quite interesting in parts) but didn't really know how to fill it with a plot. So she just wrote without a clear end goal in mind and then decides she came up with a cooler end goal several times without changing earlier chapters in accordance.
Also Florian as a main character is not really enjoyable. S/he is incredibly passive and gets pushed around by others all the time. First his central motivation is to keep his brother around and well. Then Evelyn drags him to be around her and have fun with her. During their together escape, Rake tells him to abandon his brother.
On the isles, she just abandones Evelyn because they get separated (Evelyn is being captured by soldiers) and the witch just says "Well she didn't actually want you." which Florian - a character with clearly established trust issues and natural scepticism - just believes.
Even once he made the conscious decision to abandon the witch and save Evelyn and his brother, Evelyn has already saved herself and agrees they need to return to the ship for her own reasons.
Evelyn by the way is a better character. She's a well executed "rich girl who doesn't know how the world works for poor people" that doesn't get annoying most of the time.
However I still think she's rather bland compared to Rake and Lady Ayer, two important side characters to either Flora or Evelyn, who have their own story and motivations going on with each other. Rake in fact I liked so much that my favorite DnD OC is basically him but as a woman.
They have actual defined goals and methods two achieve them. They have interesting development and foreshadowed plot twists. All things I would argue the actual main characters lack.
In fact I would say the entire story thread of the triangular relationship between the nameless pirate captain, the pirate supreme and the empire's army has all these things too while the MC's story lacks all these things.
But instead of elaborating on that, almost half of the book is spent talking about how Evelyn is imprisoned on the floating isles being bored while she waits for Flora to rescue her. Meanwhile Flora sits with the titular witch and learns the methods and lore of the magic system.
I will admit, the magic system is unique and actually interesting. There's just one problem.
It serves no purpose. It could be removed entirely and it wouldn't change a thing. Effectively all conflicts that the magic resolves are caused by the magic. In fact the story would almost benefit from removing the magic, because then the middle part would be so much less of a slog.
Also this story beat made me realize why "Oh this character seems evil, so you assume they're just weird but ultimately good. Oh surprise, they actually are just evil." is a bad and unsatisfying way to write.
Plot twist: Evil person tells the MC "You will regret this." and MC never regrets it. What was the deal with that?
Summary:
So yeah, ultimately I can see a lot of potential in this world, but it wasn't very well used. It feels like the author crammed just as many of their ideas as possible into the pages without any form of cohesion or theme.
If the focus was shifted away from Evelyn and Florian, I could see myself enjoying this. But the two and their story were just bumming me out so much and consumed so many pages that I ultimately wouldn't recommend this despite its potential.