birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

The Quiet Tenant by Clémence Michallon
3.0
dark mysterious tense slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No

This was such a well-written debut. I loved the tension Clemence Michallon infused into her thriller and I gobbled this up quickly. And if the main character—the woman held captive—had made more logical choices and (let’s face it) just done what I WOULD HAVE DONE then I would have rated it a bit higher. I really hate feeling like a main character in a thriller isn’t doing what a regular person would do. That’s so frustrating to me. I also just couldn’t quite buy the fact that a successful serial killer would bring her into his actual home like that—leaving so many things out of his control. The book itself was such a good read, but plot wise I felt it had some really glaring holes.

The Quiet Tenant is about a serial killer, Aidan, who is a beloved man about town, a family guy, extremely good looking and a great neighbour. Also, he has a woman locked in his shed. This story is told mostly through her POV and how she’s managed to be the only of his victims to survive and be kept. She has a rigid set of rules she follows but she’s always looking for that momentary opportunity to escape. There’s also a few chapters in the POV of Emily a local bartender beginning a relationship with Aidan and his daughter Cecilia.

In the end this is its most offensive flaw for me—if she’s spent 5 years looking for that one opportunity to escape—how could you let so MANY pass you by? I don’t buy it! I don’t buy it! But I did like reading it and recommend anyway as a good thriller.