While being very different than her other romance novels, this one still had me from page one. In Emily Henry fashion, we’re following two writers as they compete for the opportunity to write a coveted celebrity biography. What’s different is that we get to know this celebrity and her story very well. There are secrets, scandals, and an epic love story weaved into the backstory of this woman and it’s reminiscent of Evelyn Hugo. 

In fact, reading this made me want to go on a Taylor Jenkins Reid binge because the audiobook is narrated by the same narrator. (Julia Whelan did an incredible job, by the way.)

I adored getting to know Margaret and her family, spending time in Little Crescent, and watching our love interests fall for each other.

Now, the reason this isn’t a five star read for me is the romance. Emily Henry is my favorite romance author, so while I loved the mystery aspect this book offered, I didn’t like the lack of romantic development. I felt as if they fell for each other too quickly and too easily. The source of tension wasn’t enough for me and it felt flimsy since they weren’t trying so hard to keep their paws off of each other.

I did love the ending. With every fiber of my being!!! I loved

how Alice ended up at her mom’s and finds some common ground, how she’s working on a memoir of her own, talking about (and learning more about) her father while keeping her mother close. I loved those scenes! Then when Hayden shows up at the end clutching the letter. Just incredible writing.

Overall, I would definitely recommend giving this one a read, but keep in mind that it’s different. It still has those summer vibes and would make a great beach read. ♥️