What ifs could be fun, and there's some great fun to be had, even if some are really bad.

So first off let me tell you this is padded out because at the end it contains all the actual stories, well part of them, like Superman's death, bane breaking the bat, and so on.

The other half is the actual what if stories. So we have what if superman died and Lois lost it. What if Batman's back was broken and his replacement took over. What if Infinite Crisis didn't happen because Blue Beetle didn't die. What if Judas Contract was different. What if blackest night was even darker.

Each story has some fun to it. The weakest are for sure blackest night and Judas Contract what if. Both over the top, silly, stupid, and very fucked up for the sake of it. The Bane breaking bat what if is pretty solid though the ending is whatever. Infinite crisis is the most interesting and radical change. The lois getting superman like powers is by far the most emotional and contains some great moments.

Overall, not a bad collection. If want something different check these out. A 3 out of 5.