hongjoongie's profile picture

hongjoongie 's review for:

The Rachel Incident by Caroline O'Donoghue
4.5
emotional funny hopeful reflective
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

It was easy, now that I understood passion properly, to see why you would move heaven and earth to secure it. 
 
When something good happens to you at that age, you can't settle with the notion that it's a one-off. You want it to be the beginning of a tradition. That's how I felt about that night: I wanted it already to be a memory, a foundational one, a first evening of many similar evenings. I wanted future nostalgia, a rear-view, years-old fondness for something that had literally just happened. 
 
I came into this book worried because of the Gabrielle Zevin endorsement and because Caroline O’Donoghue mainly writes young adult fiction, but I really enjoyed it. It was nice to read a book narrated by a chaotic and slightly unhinged female narrator that I still rooted for. I loved Rachel and James’ relationship, and there were twists I enjoyed that I wasn’t expecting (
James and Dr. Bryne getting together, Rachel and Carey getting back together in the end
). What pushed this up to a 4.5 was the novel’s commentary on agency and storytelling. Contextualized against British imperialism, queer erasure, and anti-choice legislation, this book is ultimately about letting someone decide when and how to tell their own story. Through the book, Rachel gets to narrate her story, “the Rachel Incident,” on her own terms instead of it being told, shared, discussed, and manipulated by others. The book also did a good job keeping me interested and invested in the other characters, who were all realistically flawed but lovable. I would want to hear their stories too, but as Rachel says to close the novel, those are not her stories to tell. I wish the book would’ve been a little more clear on this idea. It begins with Rachel acknowledging that she’s writing the book to tell her “life experience” and she breaks the fourth wall multiple times to talk to the readers directly. This could’ve been explained further. The story also drags a little toward the end (
after the James and Dr. Bryne story fizzles out
), but then picks up again pretty quickly. Overall, a refreshing addition to the unhinged young woman canon.