I wanted to like this more than I did. I didn't dislike it because there was something wrong with it, and I'm sure many people will love it, but for me it was just an okay reading experi nice. BUT I can acknowledge that a good part of that is my fault because:
•I requested if after reading the author's previous book and loving it without knowing much about it
•if I did read the blurb at one point, it was long ago because I certainly didn't read it before I started it and I think that had me confused for a large part of it
•based on the cover and the way the story went until very nearly the end, it was unclear to me which guy would win out. It was way too much of a love triangle for someone who prefers for it to be why choose (I knew it wasn't), and because I really liked the other guy she doesn't end up with so I felt really bad for him. I honestly think if I'd read the blurb it wouldn't have felt so unclear how it was going to end and it wouldn't have bugged me as much. That said, I like the cover a lot but they are literally positioned in a triangle and I'm guessing that was intentional, so this book may just be evidence that I don't like love triangle stories. 
This won't stop me from reading more from this author in the future, and I still liked her writing even if this particular story wasn't as for me. I did appreciate seeing characters from On the Plus Side again, though!