chrisssl 's review for:

Monstrous Regiment by Terry Pratchett
5.0
adventurous dark funny hopeful fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes

This is the best Discworld novel I've read so far.  It also happens to be the darkest.  In this novel, hilarity, absurdity and mad Pratchett-style comedy are present as ever but take a notable back seat to one of the more grimmer stories in the Discworld series.  It feels rather like an outlier in Pratchett's general style (one will note a general restraint in terms of footnotes) and probably should not be recommended as an introduction to Discworld.

When I say this is Pratchett's most mature novel,  I don't mean only in terms of a small scaling back of absurd comedy (as in the City Watch subseries) or darker subject matter.  It's the craft of writing that seems to have changed as well.  Filling the pages are some of Pratchett's best prose; with less righteous anger than Going Postal and fewer pointed commentaries than Small Gods.  Here, the author's tone is somewhat more detached, allowing the harsh inequities of Borogvia love of ignorance, war and misogyny to find there way to the reader all on their own.  These injustices are pervasive throughout the setting of the novel, and yet Pratchett treats them with a very deft hand, as he does with the wonderful cast of characters, which are fantastically realized, flawed, and somewhat provincial beings not entirely aware of the great tale of social satire they find themselves swept up in.  There can be no question as to the prevailing theme of the novel, but it's delivered in a far subtler manner than ever before.  There are still the cute aphorisms at play as well as a particular moment of utter hilarity in which our protagonist is fighting against being literally relegated to the kitchens, but Pratchett largely allows the events to speak for themselves.  This is a story of disenfranchised women taking hold of their agency in the only means still available to them - through the guise of male soldiers.  And yet one would be mistaken for thinking this is some girl-boss plot with an omniscient and hyper-progressive protagonist.  While the general stupidity and myopia of male soldiers and the patriarchy are a popular source of humour in the book, it does not hesitate from introducing nuances: namely internalized misogyny, false starts of empowerment where progress is subsumed by symbolism and gender dysmorphia.

If there is any minor flaw in this novel it comes in the last third.  The novel has one key trick to play and it does so with startling emotional resonance in the first half of the book - equal parts clever and heartbreaking.  The problem is that the continued recurrence of this device loses a bit of its effectiveness, despite the fact that its clear WHY the author is choosing to use it.  And as is the case with most Discworld novels, the ending runs a tad bit too long but overall leaves the reader with a wonderful sense of having gone on a transformational journey with the main characters - a transformation which sadly outpaces any larger societal promises of reformation.  And yet, not all hope is loss.  While Pratchett correctly anticipates society's flexibility in converting subversive ideas to empty gestures (the kisses don't last), the characters leave off with a poignant lasting moment of revelation; very large themes move by very small stories, and yet these characters come to understand that they are part of a larger work and that caring for small things starts with caring for big things.  They are simply the latest rogues in a story of long defiance that began long before Polly Perks donned the uniform and became Oliver, and that will go on long after the conclusion of the novel.  And so Pratchett gives us an ending only the very best novelists can provide - full of nihilism and yet of hope.