randi_jo's profile picture

randi_jo 's review for:

The Midnight Library by Matt Haig
2.0

This is definitely a kind feel good story about life's importance and our perception of self and of our own importance. It has a very clear message: How you see life can determine how you feel about life; if you look for the good, you'll find it. If you look for the bad, you'll find it.

I really did want to enjoy this book, but I found it very difficult for a few reasons: First, Nora Seed is a difficult character to like. She is neither inherently good, nor bad, but is rather boring. Everything she does/says is highly predictable, but this may also be in part to the second complaint. The foreshadowing is SO heavy - and there are so many redundancies. I knew every life Nora was going to choose to try and live by the time I reached page ten. And of course each life would have its own set of disappointments, but the disappointments almost all ended up being that
Spoilersomeone died or someone has cheated
.

I think, at the end of the day, it was too surface level, too predictable, too ham-fisted (her last name is Seed - as in potential, the beginning of something. That is ham-fisted.). I liked the message it conveyed as someone with clinical depression, but the narrative itself was hard to get into because there was almost no tension - no conflict, nothing that made me stop and think: but what if? I have heard good things about Matt Haig as an author and plan to pick up some more of his work, as I think this one just might not have been his best.