mathildur's profile picture

mathildur 's review for:

Mooncakes by Suzanne Walker
5.0

E-arc provided by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

I wanted to read Mooncakes because it looked soft and cute while still being magical and I was very pleased to discover I was right. Mooncakes is about two teens: Nova, a Chinese-American witch living with her two grandmothers, and Tam, a Chinese-American non-binary werewolf. The story begins with Nova exploring a rumor of a white wolf in the woods close to her house and finding her childhood crush Tam fighting with a horse demon. The book goes on to deal with the intricate bonds of family, both old and new, and with trying to find your own way in a confusing world of expectations.

This graphic novel has it all: amazing drawings, lgbtq representation (F+NB), disabled representation (Nova has a hearing disability), magic, mythical beings, cute grandma witches who are friends with the spirits in their garden, teenage angst, banter, puns. You name it, the book has it! I loved reading about Nova and Tam. I loved the magic and the witchcraft, both used in the everyday life and to fight demons. I loved the drawings and the artwork, the style fit the story perfectly!

If I had to find one thing I disliked about the book, it has to be the fact that is was over too quickly. I wish it was longer! Both because I want to read more about the awesome characters, but also because I wish we had been given more backstory to the character arcs. I suppose it is not normal for graphic novels to contain the same amount of slow world- and character-building as a huge novel, but I can still wish for it right? I just feel like it would have been nice to know more about the magic system, as well as about Nova and Tam and their futures. The ending was a little bit abrupt, but maybe it hints at a sequel at some point? I sure hope so, because I loved this book so much!!

To conclude: this graphic novel is amazing, definitely go get it when it publishes in October!!