awesomeeallyson's profile picture

awesomeeallyson 's review for:

The City We Became by N.K. Jemisin
3.75
adventurous challenging funny medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

The City We Became was such a weird and totally out there book. I loved the concept and N.K. Jemison clearly, clearly loves the city she lives in. This book is incredibly inventive, incredibly unique and beautifully written. I just love the intention and concept of this book so much. As someone who has never read N.K. Jemison before, I can understand why she is such a well-known author and I am definitely going to be checking out her other books. I mean, I love fantasy! How have I not read something by her yet? 

I think the big issue with this book, and the main thing that kept tripping me up, is that the big bad villain is a concept, kind of? Even at the end of the book the main characters still don't really understand how or why the evil works. It's clear that it's not fully beaten so there's definitely going to be another follow up book. But the first half of this book you spend meeting the characters and learning who they are. You see the evil thing from their perspective but since they also don't know anything about it's just a lot of confusion and speculation. Even when other characters join in to help, they are still confused and unsure. This in itself creates a huge learning curve when you dive in.  

I don't think this is a reflection of Jemisin's writing. I think she did an incredible job for what she was creating, but the concept itself is so ambiguous that it's hard to grasp as a reader. However, there's some small comfort in knowing that the characters themselves are just as confused as you are. 

I think this book suffers from something that a lot first books in a new series suffer from: too much world building and background to have an exciting story line. Not to say that nothing happens. I still had a hard time putting the book down when I really got into it. This sets the first book up to be a little slow moving. I think the rest of the books in the series are really going to pick up and be much better.