birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

3.0
challenging dark mysterious slow-paced

A debut filled with a mix of native lore and mystery, Nick Medina sets his story of missing indigenous women on a fictional reservation but the trauma is universal. 

Anna Horn is struggling with bullies and a widening chasm between her and her younger sister when women start to go missing after being seen at their tribe’s new casino and resort. On a new evening shift as a housekeeper her boss Fox seems as wiley as his name. When her own sister goes missing she’ll stop at nothing to find her.

I found this an enjoyable enough read but felt it was at least 100 pages too long—there was a lot of repetition and reiteration of the same info. I think Medina needed to trust his readers more, often the themes (like Anna’s story-keeping role and maybe being two-spirited) and crucial info (the who, whats, and where’s of the mystery) felt heavy-handed. The story meanders a bit and the mystery was good but could have used a bit more focus and clean editing to make the suspense sing. 

On the personal side, one of the bits of native lore revolve around a decapitated rolling head… and I’m sorry… it was just not scary at all. There’s so many spookier stories or bits of lore he could have played with, I’m not sure why that one got the spotlight. It ended up reading more campy than spooky for me. But that could be a me problem, for sure.

All that said, it was a good debut and I’m always happy to support a new indigenous writer—I enjoyed the story he had in Never Whistle at Night. I think I just didn’t vibe with some of the choices he made for this book. I still think this one is worth reading.