Take a photo of a barcode or cover
candelibri 's review for:
Sunrise On The Reaping
by Suzanne Collins
medium-paced
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Hmm. Ok. See if you can follow me as I work my way through this review bc I had a lot of thoughts as I read this and I’m still trying to order them.
Right off the bat, this feels like a “fan service” novel. This wasn’t written because Collins had something important to add to the world or something to say - it was purely “for the vibes.” And while I’m usually all for it, I feel like this was a really missed opportunity to add to the socio-political discourse that Hunger Games did such a good job it introducing when it first came out. This book did none of that - in fact, it felt like a lot of cutting and pasting of pieces of Catching Fire as well as Hunger Games. From a nostalgia standpoint: loved it. From a revisiting standpoint: snoozefest.
Haymitch as a character had SO much promise and considering how much time was spent on him, I was expecting a lot more yet he felt very two-dimensional - loves Lenore Dove (omg must we address her by her full government name EVERY time we talk about her??) and hates Snow.
Seriously. Those are the two things. There was no mystery, no narrative arc. And oh btw, loves his family but only just enough at the beginning to miss them and enough at the end to be heartbroken but then he gets distracted when he wants to go find Lenore Dove. Continuity isn’t his strong suit, y’all.
But honestly; the love story was not fleshed out enough for me to feel invested and the villain storyline of “hating Snow” felt forced. All you hear is “Snow is going to kill me.” But WHY. What makes Haymitch more of an archnemesis than Katniss??
All of which resulted in a lot of showing me things about Haymitch and not letting me get to know him. So does Collins explain how we get the Haymitch of the HG trilogy? Yes. Does she do him justice in this book? Not for me. At the end of the day, I was left with a complete feeling of uninterest in Haymitch and I lay that squarely on the author bc I LOVED Haymitch in the trilogy.
And dear lord WHAT is with the Edgar Allan Poe?? And gumdrops?? Talk about taking me out of the world. Listen, I love ravens as much as the next person but ma’am you are ruining your entire world!
_______
Updated to add:
Things that would have made this book better:
IMAGINE IF THIS STORY WAS TOLD FROM PLUTARCH’S POV?? God, I wish.
Before this, all of the previous HG books had subtle moving parts that made you sit up and take notice, that made them narratively richer and gave their characters more depth. That was severely lacking here.
Right off the bat, this feels like a “fan service” novel. This wasn’t written because Collins had something important to add to the world or something to say - it was purely “for the vibes.” And while I’m usually all for it, I feel like this was a really missed opportunity to add to the socio-political discourse that Hunger Games did such a good job it introducing when it first came out. This book did none of that - in fact, it felt like a lot of cutting and pasting of pieces of Catching Fire as well as Hunger Games. From a nostalgia standpoint: loved it. From a revisiting standpoint: snoozefest.
Haymitch as a character had SO much promise and considering how much time was spent on him, I was expecting a lot more yet he felt very two-dimensional - loves Lenore Dove (omg must we address her by her full government name EVERY time we talk about her??) and hates Snow.
Seriously. Those are the two things. There was no mystery, no narrative arc. And oh btw, loves his family but only just enough at the beginning to miss them and enough at the end to be heartbroken but then he gets distracted when he wants to go find Lenore Dove. Continuity isn’t his strong suit, y’all.
But honestly; the love story was not fleshed out enough for me to feel invested and the villain storyline of “hating Snow” felt forced. All you hear is “Snow is going to kill me.” But WHY. What makes Haymitch more of an archnemesis than Katniss??
All of which resulted in a lot of showing me things about Haymitch and not letting me get to know him. So does Collins explain how we get the Haymitch of the HG trilogy? Yes. Does she do him justice in this book? Not for me. At the end of the day, I was left with a complete feeling of uninterest in Haymitch and I lay that squarely on the author bc I LOVED Haymitch in the trilogy.
And dear lord WHAT is with the Edgar Allan Poe?? And gumdrops?? Talk about taking me out of the world. Listen, I love ravens as much as the next person but ma’am you are ruining your entire world!
_______
Updated to add:
Things that would have made this book better:
IMAGINE IF THIS STORY WAS TOLD FROM PLUTARCH’S POV?? God, I wish.
Before this, all of the previous HG books had subtle moving parts that made you sit up and take notice, that made them narratively richer and gave their characters more depth. That was severely lacking here.