Cornelli is only ten years old, and her whole world is about to change. Her father decides that Cornelli needs a mother-figure in her life, and invites a sharp adult cousin to visit and give Cornelli an "education" in manners. Cornelli is forced to "speak when spoken to" and sit up straight and always be perfectly tidy. She is not allowed to run or shout. She is not allowed to visit the newborn goat kid in the barn. Her cousin tells her that if she is disagreeable then no one will ever like her, and if she is disobedient then devil's horns will grow out of her forehead. Cornelli is terrified, and her father is confused about why his sweet daughter is suddenly sullen and obstinate. It will take the love of a special family and the advice of a kind neighbor lady to soothe Cornelli's fears and bring her sweet personality back.

I loved this book so much! I liked the simple writing style that takes deep themes and explains them with common sense. The story line is full of deep character analysis, and I loved seeing how the relationships between the characters unfolded. And yet, it is simple and plain enough for a child to read and understand.

I adored Cornelli's character! She has such a complex and sensitive personality. Her character arc is very similar to Mary Lennox in The Secret Garden. She has a sweet nature and merry disposition, but she is plagued by fears that everyone will hate her. She is downtrodden and depressed by her older cousin who bullies her. But gradually we see her natural personality blossom again when she is surrounded by love and kindness once more.

I love the supporting characters who help Cornelli and show her affection! Mrs. Halm is so patient with Cornelli and provides a safe haven for her. The entire Halm family is so sweet, but not too saccharine. They have their own sorrows and difficulties that make them fractious and even unfriendly at times. It just makes their characters more interesting!

The truest friend who sticks with Cornelli through it all is the old neighbor lady, Martha. She is wise and kind and always points Cornelli to God as the best help in times of trouble. The two pray together and Martha reminds Cornelli to trust in God's providence. It's very touching and emotional! I love the spiritual messages in this book!

Cornelli's father is not really a bad guy; he's just so busy with his work, and he does not really know what children need. He is smart enough to rely on the wisdom of others to help him rear his child, but doesn't always select the best counselors (like that horrible cousin).