ninadisalvo's profile picture

ninadisalvo 's review for:

Extracts From: The Second Sex by Simone de Beauvoir
3.75
challenging informative reflective medium-paced

On the whole, I really enjoyed Simone de Beauvoir's perspective on the independent woman, women's constraints during the time of her writing this book in the 1940's, and the lack of mutual equality between men and women. This is certainly not a new issue, that of women's issues in society, careers, artistry, relationships (romantic, familial, or otherwise), etc., and one that persists today, though with some variation.

Some of the perspectives in this book are dated, and I found her narrowed, intense focus on female narcissism to be a bit problematic, though I understand her articulated perspective. Any gender can be a clinical narcissist; however, across history women have been more often labeled narcissistic when they were in a position of disagreement with a male figure and began articulating their perspective. There is also the reality of societal survival in patriarchal communities where it is, unfortunately, critical for women to conform to female expectations (whether in dress, behavior, personal interest, etc) in order to not be banned, shunned, shamed, harassed, and bullied by the group at large. Not all of us are blessed to be around like minded colleagues. This increases the challenges women face to pursue and independent life outside of male ownership, misogny, and abuse. In this book, de Beauvoir goes on in great detail about the type of women she views as the problem, and while she does go into some detail about mens faults, she seems to be scolding women for their role in women's issues for the majority of the book. 

On the first page of the Chapter 14: The Independent Woman section, I wrote: "Damn this woman's writing came out of her like a canon" and for the beginning of this section her writing truly electric. I was underlining, highlighting, and writing notes in the margins for almost every page. Until, again, she had an incessantly negative view on women, from her view, were the problem for conforming to the universal female archetype and 'played the part', when for many women pursuing beauty is pursuing a safety shield, and not an act of vanity. Some women do make the pointed decision to conform/submit in certain settings in order to remain safe, but I don't think we should necessarily condem them for this. This shape-shifting was not discussed in the book, though people pleasing was of course (which is such a common issue for us ladies, we really have no choice in youth because of how aggressively we are shamed, guilded, reprimanded by folks responsible and not responsible for us, etc), but I think it could be an interesting spring-board conversation from this text. Again, this book is a bit dated, but not invaluable and certainly can initiate some creative thought and thoughtful discourse around women's issues. I would recommend this short (113 pages) concise book for those interested in the material.

As a side note, I enjoyed the references to other writers of the time, such as Colette, and those of a more recent history such as Emily Bronte, Jane Austen, Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, it was cool to see these authors written about by another author during a closer time period then today, where they are all household names for literature fiends.