I didn’t read the blurb of this book. The blurb said it was “perfect for fans of TJ Klune,” and has a stunning cover. His books are thought-provoking, and endearing, and you can’t get enough. This book did not compare. I buddy-read this with Leah and Julie. We all kind of ended up in the same place, but Julie didn’t finish it.

The premise of this book was so interesting! I think the use of letters/transcripts could have been so cool. I do enjoy an epistolary-style book from time to time. Unfortunately, this book suffered from it because there were not enough distinctive voices. All the letters blended in, and each character felt/sounded the same. I also wish there was a time stamp on them. There’s no telling how much time has passed for most of the letters/messages. It made it harder to track timing.

I talked a little about the characters all sounding the same. I did think that E and Henerey were the most interesting characters. I loved seeing their relationship blossom! I think E’s writing was the most distinct because it was so full of anxiety. I did appreciate that the author went there, but it was sometimes a little hard to read.

The underwater settings and creatures were the most interesting part of this book! I do wish we could have delved a little deeper into that aspect. There was so much mystery involved and not enough payout. It left me wanting so much more and having many more questions.

Overall, I was excited about this one and really let down. I’m so bummed because it has such a great premise and a stunning cover! While the writing style was not for me, I can see how many others would enjoy it.

Thank you to Orbit for an ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.