I want to preface this review by saying I haven’t actually read ‘The Picture of Dorian Gray’ which this book is ‘retelling’ 🫣. Therefore my view may be swayed by plot points and characteristics better attributed to the original story than this retelling - but feel that I just have to reflect on my enjoyment with this book and it’s writing rather than the core plot premise.

I was suprised by how much I enjoyed this book as I’m usually not the biggest fan of YA but the dark academia and sapphic vibes were so engrossing.

The romance, mental health/eating struggles and academic rivalry created some interesting character development opportunities for Penny and the plot. 

I REALLY enjoyed the master and servant acting class situation. It created such tension and dark vibes. Immaculate.

I was quite taken aback by the very vulnerable and genuine writing around the pressure of beauty standards and mentality around eating disorders. Felt very well written and brought a level of depth I enjoy in my books.

I did feel the reveal and resolution became very heavy on the “magic” which took me out of the story a little and felt almost chaotic.

I mean guarding swans and a mirror labyrinth accessed by the bottom of a lake felt so random and out of place.

I wish it had stayed a bit more grounded in reality.  I also had to knock my rating back due to the overuse and repetition of certain words and phrases in the writing. 

Overall a really fun and enjoyable read with some really interesting characters. I am definitely curious to pick up the original Dorian gray story.