Take a photo of a barcode or cover
illustrated_librarian 's review for:
The Ballad of Jacquotte Delahaye
by Briony Cameron
adventurous
emotional
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
Working as a shipwright in Santo Domingo Jacquotte dreams of broader horizons, away from her erratic and selfish father. But when uproar forces her to flee with a motley crew of companions, their new life as indentures aboard a pirate ship isn't what she had in mind. Under the ruthless Captain Blackhand life is tough, but Jacquotte sees a chance to rise and claim her freedom, and a better life for her friends.
I have mixed feelings on this one, so let's start with what worked. Firstly, Cameron's scene-setting was fantastic. If you've watched any Pirates of the Carribean films, the ships and pirate towns leap off the page in all their gritty, chaotic glory. And this is extremely gritty — there's a satisfying amount of swashbuckling and spilled blood across some very well-done action scenes; they felt high-stakes and intentionally deployed for Jacquotte's journey.
Amidst the struggle of shipboard life, Cameron made sure to highlight queer joy (there's a deliberate lack of homophobia in this world, it's historical *fiction* after all) and the safe harbour of a found family who back you through thick and thin. The side characters were endearing, if not the most developed, and gave Jacquotte a reason to fight fiercely for her people.
The prose style is quite basic and could feel lacking in the slower sections, but worked well for the action as it kept a punchy pace. Where this really fell down for me was in the broader plot and pacing — there were plot holes too glaring to overlook and contradictions that should have been picked up in an edit, plus some hand-wavey treatment of injuries and illnesses that disappeared once inconvenient.
A multi-pov approach could have really elevated the pacing and characters, especially in terms of deepening the relationship between Jacquotte and Teresa. It was sweet but shallow, and I wished we'd got more of them on the page!
Despite this, it's undeniably FUN, even as it addresses tougher social justice topics. High seas! Heists! Swordfights! Canonfire! Gay pirates! I was undoubtedly entertained, and I'm not mad I read it.