This book isn't as good as The Giver. It lacks some of The Giver's underlying charm and simplicity. I also feel that it's a bit more geared toward a younger audience. Where The Giver can be appreciated regardless of age, I felt this would be more enjoyed by a kid. However, I thoroughly enjoyed this book on its own. Kira is a compelling main character and it's a very different kind of village. The story didn't have as satisfying an arc, but the ending left me immediately grabbing for Messenger, which I have already started, and I'm looking forward to the conclusion of the series.