I loved the characters of Morgan and Eli. I loved how the author shines a light on the Canadian foster care system. I think that if this book was realistic fiction, I would have enjoyed it more. I had trouble following the fantasy story-line and keeping track of the elements involved. Unfortunately I have never read nor had a personal interest in reading Narnia which this book is compared to, and that may have impacted my enjoyment of the book. 

That all being said, I know I'm not the target audience for this book. I will still recommend this to middle-grade readers. I think it is an important series for Canadian youth. I think it is core Canadian middle grade fiction. I will check out more of David A. Robertson's books, but I just might not continue this series.