I haven't completely finished this book yet. I am most of the way through it and I do like and enjoy most of the stories but it is a very large collection and takes a whole to get through.
Sherlock Holmes is a joy to read and a collection like this is great to have since you can read it in spirts if you wish.
I gave it three stars because I find that the later stories are not as great or surprising as the earlier ones.
A good collection and a good read.