I'm not sure I would ever be able to give this book a fair review, having seen the movie so many times and loved it for the shining example of a chick flick that it is, and sure enough it was impossible to read it without thinking of all the ways it deviates from the movie (and sometimes, in the most truly bizarre ways). While this book is probably not getting a fair, objective reading from me, I strongly suspect it's one of those times where the movie is genuinely better than the book.