This was much more enjoyable over all than the Red Queen. Elizabeth’s story was top-notch as was Nicholas’. I wasn’t as much of a fan of Girl in Amber as it felt repetitive at that point and added little development for Alice’s character, but I did appreciate that Alice was as sick of the repetition as the reader feels. Overall, three of the four shorts were five stars, and I’d put Girl in Amber at three stars, so I’m averaging the book out to a 4.